A moral victory then...or 'if it wasn't for the ref' victory?Which Tyler wrote:Especially if it forces a hung parliament when predictions were a 100-120 seat conservative victory.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
It'd be like Wales forcing a draw against the All Blacks
Snap General Election called
-
- Posts: 4503
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:46 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
- Which Tyler
- Posts: 9359
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:43 pm
- Location: Tewkesbury
- Contact:
Re: Snap General Election called
Oh, moral victory for shewer.WaspInWales wrote:A moral victory then...or 'if it wasn't for the ref' victory?Which Tyler wrote:Especially if it forces a hung parliament when predictions were a 100-120 seat conservative victory.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
It'd be like Wales forcing a draw against the All Blacks
Oh, and this ETA: https://mobile.twitter.com/LostUKIPdeposit
-
- Posts: 4503
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:46 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
That may well be the best use of Twitter...ever.Which Tyler wrote:Oh, moral victory for shewer.WaspInWales wrote:A moral victory then...or 'if it wasn't for the ref' victory?Which Tyler wrote: Especially if it forces a hung parliament when predictions were a 100-120 seat conservative victory.
It'd be like Wales forcing a draw against the All Blacks
Oh, and this ETA: https://mobile.twitter.com/LostUKIPdeposit
- Sandydragon
- Posts: 10299
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:13 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
Some were reasonably close.Stom wrote:The exit poll got close last time out...Mellsblue wrote:Except for the one prior to this.......Stom wrote:
The exit polls have been quite reliable recently, though...
It will be interesting, then. When I get up around 6 UK time, it'll be very interesting to see exactly where we are with seats declared.
BBC repeatedly saying that this is based on a lot of 50/50 constituency falling the correct way. Still, you can't see it being that far wrong surely.
The normal polls got it all wrong.
So we will have a Tory DUP coalition of sorts I expect. Brexit negotiations will be interesting as every Tory mp will see an opportunity to make their voice heard. With that range of opinion, i expect may will need some labour support at some point.
Interesting that the Tory vote is actually up on last time (% wise), I can't remember the last time a sitting government managed that and lost seats. Th ecollapse of ukip is having a huge impact.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Snap General Election called
I'd say no as they should never have had such low expectations. To label them winners would be like calling Neil Kinnock a winner, and nobody does that.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
Either of our major parties should be winning a 3rd election to get back into government, so Labour's results today are akin to the Tories under Michael Howard, and again nobody calls him a winner, though people tend to be very happy to call him a loser
- canta_brian
- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:52 pm
Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
You on drugs?Digby wrote:I'd say no as they should never have had such low expectations. To label them winners would be like calling Neil Kinnock a winner, and nobody does that.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
Either of our major parties should be winning a 3rd election to get back into government, so Labour's results today are akin to the Tories under Michael Howard, and again nobody calls him a winner, though people tend to be very happy to call him a loser
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
-
- Posts: 615
- Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:47 pm
Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
It's amazing what Corbin achieved in such a short time, finally getting some unfiltered press. The real losers are the Blairites who jumped ship because he was "unelectable", imagine what could have been achieved if they hadn't been squabbling for the last 2 years?canta_brian wrote:You on drugs?Digby wrote:I'd say no as they should never have had such low expectations. To label them winners would be like calling Neil Kinnock a winner, and nobody does that.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
Either of our major parties should be winning a 3rd election to get back into government, so Labour's results today are akin to the Tories under Michael Howard, and again nobody calls him a winner, though people tend to be very happy to call him a loser
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
BBC correspondent saying a handful of Labour MPs who appeared on their coverage had prewritten speeches prepared to rubbish Corbyn and call for his resignation, again. Apparently had to rush to prepare something nice to say
- Mellsblue
- Posts: 16084
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am
Re: Snap General Election called
Is it amazing? Running on a manifesto that promised the world to all but those nasty people who earn a lot, if you can call £80,000 in the south east a lot, that was economically illiterate and was rubbished by the IFS, and that had only a slim chance of actually being fulfilled. He was also running against a government that presided over seven years of austerity and that ran an utterly woeful campaign. He had Remainers handed to him on a plate in pro-EU seats in which the Lib Dems weren't a viable option and yet he still didn't win or get close to having the numbers to form a coalition.
Last edited by Mellsblue on Fri Jun 09, 2017 8:06 am, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
Well I was drinking herb tea last night, but as that was just Twinings Lemon & Ginger I suspect I'd be okay.canta_brian wrote:You on drugs?Digby wrote:I'd say no as they should never have had such low expectations. To label them winners would be like calling Neil Kinnock a winner, and nobody does that.Peat wrote:Doing a lot better than expected is certainly a form of victory, no?
Either of our major parties should be winning a 3rd election to get back into government, so Labour's results today are akin to the Tories under Michael Howard, and again nobody calls him a winner, though people tend to be very happy to call him a loser
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
And my point is the Labour party should have never been trailing like that, it's absurd to even remotely defend that when they're up against a 3rd term austerity Tory opposition. And even absent of that being odd seats behind isn't a win, it's a loss.
Corbyn has done better than Milliband, but that's not good enough.
-
- Posts: 615
- Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:47 pm
Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
But you refuse to accept the reason why they are so far behind is in-fighting, and place all of the blame for that infighting on the elected leader rather than those under him causing the problems in the first place.Digby wrote:Well I was drinking herb tea last night, but as that was just Twinings Lemon & Ginger I suspect I'd be okay.canta_brian wrote:You on drugs?Digby wrote:
I'd say no as they should never have had such low expectations. To label them winners would be like calling Neil Kinnock a winner, and nobody does that.
Either of our major parties should be winning a 3rd election to get back into government, so Labour's results today are akin to the Tories under Michael Howard, and again nobody calls him a winner, though people tend to be very happy to call him a loser
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
And my point is the Labour party should have never been trailing like that, it's absurd to even remotely defend that when they're up against a 3rd term austerity Tory opposition. And even absent of that being odd seats behind isn't a win, it's a loss.
Corbyn has done better than Milliband, but that's not good enough.
You are completely right this is not where Labour should be, the last 2 years have been an absolute writeoff and basically only started acting like the party should a couple of months ago.
-
- Posts: 615
- Joined: Wed Feb 17, 2016 4:47 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
Little turds like Owen Jones have done an unsurprising u-turn, a man who for 2 years was unelectable despite never running an election campaign is all of a sudden "fine prime minister material".
-
- Posts: 1038
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:09 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
Twinings Lemon & Ginger is the shiznit. Good choice man.
Yeah, Labour should never have been in this position, but there's only so much blame that can be apportioned to Corbyn here. He had very little to do with landing them in the hole and, while he could have done a better job digging them out prior to this election, he was well up against it. And he did pretty much the best imaginable job here.
It is pretty pathetic that the Labour's busy going "Whoo hoo" when in reality they've still come behind a party that haven't been able to win a clean majority since 1992. Oops, sorry, did it once. Pathetic from both. We live in an age of political pygmies.
Yeah, Labour should never have been in this position, but there's only so much blame that can be apportioned to Corbyn here. He had very little to do with landing them in the hole and, while he could have done a better job digging them out prior to this election, he was well up against it. And he did pretty much the best imaginable job here.
It is pretty pathetic that the Labour's busy going "Whoo hoo" when in reality they've still come behind a party that haven't been able to win a clean majority since 1992. Oops, sorry, did it once. Pathetic from both. We live in an age of political pygmies.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
Maybe the infighting is part of the reason, but every party leader has to contend with that. How you control that or not is part of what you're judged on, it's not an issue one should use to absolve a party leaderjared_7 wrote:But you refuse to accept the reason why they are so far behind is in-fighting, and place all of the blame for that infighting on the elected leader rather than those under him causing the problems in the first place.Digby wrote:Well I was drinking herb tea last night, but as that was just Twinings Lemon & Ginger I suspect I'd be okay.canta_brian wrote: You on drugs?
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
And my point is the Labour party should have never been trailing like that, it's absurd to even remotely defend that when they're up against a 3rd term austerity Tory opposition. And even absent of that being odd seats behind isn't a win, it's a loss.
Corbyn has done better than Milliband, but that's not good enough.
You are completely right this is not where Labour should be, the last 2 years have been an absolute writeoff and basically only started acting like the party should a couple of months ago.
- canta_brian
- Posts: 1285
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:52 pm
Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
Seems Corbyn has played a blinder. May, on the other hand. Seems May is refusing to step down if Lauren Knussb... Keunsber... Oh what's her name, is correct. That's just wonderful. Her obvious talent is just what we need going into the brexit negotiations in 11 days.jared_7 wrote:But you refuse to accept the reason why they are so far behind is in-fighting, and place all of the blame for that infighting on the elected leader rather than those under him causing the problems in the first place.Digby wrote:Well I was drinking herb tea last night, but as that was just Twinings Lemon & Ginger I suspect I'd be okay.canta_brian wrote: You on drugs?
Tory called snap election on the back of huge poll numbers. Corbyn being written off by pretty much every person in Britain. Result, hung parliament. To suggest that this is not a victory for Labour and Corbyn in particular is just churlish.
And my point is the Labour party should have never been trailing like that, it's absurd to even remotely defend that when they're up against a 3rd term austerity Tory opposition. And even absent of that being odd seats behind isn't a win, it's a loss.
Corbyn has done better than Milliband, but that's not good enough.
You are completely right this is not where Labour should be, the last 2 years have been an absolute writeoff and basically only started acting like the party should a couple of months ago.
So she supported remain
Flipped to leave to get the top job
Flipped to call a snap election thinking labour were down and out
Made a twat of herself by saying the Europeans were being mean after that number 10 dinner
Lost a parliamentary majority with big gains to the unelectable Corbyn.
She'll do just fine in the brexit negotiations. She's obviously a talent.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Snap General Election called
You say that, but it seems like only the other week I'd have been staying up for much of the election if not all of it whilst drinking champagne.Peat wrote:Twinings Lemon & Ginger is the shiznit. Good choice man.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: RE: Re: RE: Re: Snap General Election called
Kuenssberg.canta_brian wrote:Seems May is refusing to step down if Lauren Knussb... Keunsber... Oh what's her name, is correct. That's just wonderful. Her obvious talent is just what we need going into the brexit negotiations in 11 days.
May will not last until the next election as she'd not be allowed to fight it even if she wants to. Whether the Tories seek an immediate new leader, whether they try to make some progress on Brexit first allowing May to take some hits so the new person can step in to sort it out, whether May simply quite, whether even we ask the EU for a stay of execution on leaving the EU I don't know, and really they're not likely to know just 5-6 hours later after the scale of their disastrous night was confirmed.
- Sandydragon
- Posts: 10299
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:13 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
There is no way that May will lead another election campaign. None. The only reason she isn't busy packing right now, and I understand the likes of BoJo are taking soundings, is that a leadership contest now would be a disaster. Brexit is happening and we can't piss about with a leadership contest now. Once we have a deal in place, I expect those knives being sharpened to be deployed.
It's also in a lot of people's interests to keep May in place. Many Tories don't want Boris but there aren't too many contenders at the moment. I'm not sure Corbyn would want her to go either. If he takes the long view, he is in a great position. He has gained additional seats and regained votes from ukip and other protest parties. He can now watch a weakened PM take the full rap for Brexit whilst chucking grenades in from the sidelines and hoping to capitalise if the Tories fall apart, which given the volatility of the conservative right wing, is quite likely, particularly if May has to compromise and get support of other parties.
Better for Corbyn to have come a close second last night and look to capitalise in a few years time, as I don't think this government will last 5 years.
It's also in a lot of people's interests to keep May in place. Many Tories don't want Boris but there aren't too many contenders at the moment. I'm not sure Corbyn would want her to go either. If he takes the long view, he is in a great position. He has gained additional seats and regained votes from ukip and other protest parties. He can now watch a weakened PM take the full rap for Brexit whilst chucking grenades in from the sidelines and hoping to capitalise if the Tories fall apart, which given the volatility of the conservative right wing, is quite likely, particularly if May has to compromise and get support of other parties.
Better for Corbyn to have come a close second last night and look to capitalise in a few years time, as I don't think this government will last 5 years.
-
- Posts: 1038
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:09 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
Champagne is heavily overrated.Digby wrote:You say that, but it seems like only the other week I'd have been staying up for much of the election if not all of it whilst drinking champagne.Peat wrote:Twinings Lemon & Ginger is the shiznit. Good choice man.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Snap General Election called
I agree, and normally I'd consider sparkling wine a better and cheaper alternative. But sometimes it's just a time for champagnePeat wrote:Champagne is heavily overrated.Digby wrote:You say that, but it seems like only the other week I'd have been staying up for much of the election if not all of it whilst drinking champagne.Peat wrote:Twinings Lemon & Ginger is the shiznit. Good choice man.
-
- Posts: 5576
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:49 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
Once again regardless of content of her campaign Ruth Davidson has had a positive night in Scotland. Tory HQ might keep an eye on that one and get her involved. She seems to know how to strike a chord with the electorate in Scotland.
-
- Posts: 20888
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
indeed, polar opposite to May in terms of charisma, energy and debatingBig D wrote:Once again regardless of content of her campaign Ruth Davidson has had a positive night in Scotland. Tory HQ might keep an eye on that one and get her involved. She seems to know how to strike a chord with the electorate in Scotland.
-
- Posts: 20888
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
McDonnell wants to form a coalition government
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: Snap General Election called
Does he say wants? Though no matter what he wants close friends may persuade him it's in the best interests of the country for him to put aside what he wants and take any opportunity to serve.Banquo wrote:McDonnell wants to form a coalition government
-
- Posts: 20888
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm
Re: Snap General Election called
just heard him say itDigby wrote:Does he say wants? Though no matter what he wants close friends may persuade him it's in the best interests of the country for him to put aside what he wants and take any opportunity to serve.Banquo wrote:McDonnell wants to form a coalition government
- Stom
- Posts: 5939
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 10:57 am
Re: Snap General Election called
Did he not say Minority Government? With policy by policy support.Banquo wrote:McDonnell wants to form a coalition government
Could we have competing Queen's Speeches?