Cough, ...Tom...Crof....Cough!TheNomad wrote:
He can be very eye catching, and he's rapid for his size - all of which is great - but as a test back row you, IMO can't afford to get through as little dirty work as he does.

Moderator: Puja
Cough, ...Tom...Crof....Cough!TheNomad wrote:
He can be very eye catching, and he's rapid for his size - all of which is great - but as a test back row you, IMO can't afford to get through as little dirty work as he does.
and an even bigger belly to fillMikey Brown wrote: He's got big shoes to fill at 8 for Quins this year so we'll see how he handles that.
Good to see Steffon Armitage in fine form!TheNomad wrote:
Let's just poach this kid
Depends on what the coach wants. As a naturally-gifyer rugby player, Slade is far ahead of those other two. I think we will see less and less of Hill, a centre with some power but limited ability - Jamie Roberts lite.TheNomad wrote:At test level, to be honest he's probably a 10, capable of playing 12. I don't think he's a 13. Will be interesting to see where he settles in a few years...maybe he won't...but I think the issue is that he's unlikely to be playing at 12 for Exeter with Hill and Devoto there.
Agreed. Unless Hill pulls a Mike Brown-esque jump in ability out of his hat in the next season, he's going to be the loser in that centre battle.Spiffy wrote:Depends on what the coach wants. As a naturally-gifyer rugby player, Slade is far ahead of those other two. I think we will see less and less of Hill, a centre with some power but limited ability - Jamie Roberts lite.TheNomad wrote:At test level, to be honest he's probably a 10, capable of playing 12. I don't think he's a 13. Will be interesting to see where he settles in a few years...maybe he won't...but I think the issue is that he's unlikely to be playing at 12 for Exeter with Hill and Devoto there.
Clark's a younger version of Hill, with a bit more pace; I'd happily take Devo back, or give Slade a home at 12 though.Digby wrote:Hill could do worse than move to Bath
You are Chris Ashton and I claim my £5.TheNomad wrote:Ooh! Will get my teeth into that tomorrow
So have you put all that together long hand (i.e. from ESPN Scrum etc.), or is there a good source that I'm missing? Can't find it on statbunkerWhich Tyler wrote:Some more stats ready - I know you guys just love them!
Stats for the provisional EPS squad, for the 2015/16 Premiership (+6N). Also included is kicking stats for the entirety 2014/15/16 seasons.
Second set is averages for all stats per 80 minutes played (ie total / minutes played x 80) - except kicking stats; which is just kicking averages - split by conversions and penalties as requested (you bastard!)
Stats from ESPN - not quite long-hand; it was actually easier to cut-and-paste the entire team's worth of stat.s into Excel, and then just re-arrange things, and pick out the EPS squad members - also means I've got the lot (excepting Worcester's starting THP for each match - according to ESPN they never bothered with one), so when he names his actual EPS, it'll take about 2 minutes to update this.TheNomad wrote:So have you put all that together long hand (i.e. from ESPN Scrum etc.), or is there a good source that I'm missing? Can't find it on statbunker
It's a question a lot of people have been asking for just over a year. The answer is beyond me. I'm sure it'll happen in time and it's one of the ones that will have to happen for us to win the World Cup.Stom wrote:Without going into it in detail, I just have one comment:
How the hell is Hartley ahead of George! That guy is insane. Runs 5 times more per game than Hartley, makes more tackles, misses fewer, concedes fewer penalties...
Kicking cricket balls and running around with your jumper over your head, again?Which Tyler wrote:You can still thank a broken toe which has kept me at home, and bored all week for putting them together thoughTheNomad wrote:So have you put all that together long hand (i.e. from ESPN Scrum etc.), or is there a good source that I'm missing? Can't find it on statbunker
Nothing so dramatic - more a failure to react quickly enough* when approached by a 55kg dog going full-pelt with half a tree in her mouth.Mellsblue wrote:Kicking cricket balls and running around with your jumper over your head, again?Which Tyler wrote:You can still thank a broken toe which has kept me at home, and bored all week for putting them together thoughTheNomad wrote:So have you put all that together long hand (i.e. from ESPN Scrum etc.), or is there a good source that I'm missing? Can't find it on statbunker
I'll give it a couple of days, but if we gather a list of players who's stats we want to see; to compare for ourselves, and I'll get on it.Beasties wrote:Be interesting to know what Tommy Taylor's stats are in relation to Hartley and George, especially he's now at a bigger club.
Ollie Devoto and Matt Smith.Which Tyler wrote:I'll give it a couple of days, but if we gather a list of players who's stats we want to see; to compare for ourselves, and I'll get on it.Beasties wrote:Be interesting to know what Tommy Taylor's stats are in relation to Hartley and George, especially he's now at a bigger club.
Won't take long now that I've gathered all the data and got it set.
Premiership players only though (as of 2015/16)!
How very dare you. Hartley is our awesome captain who's transformed us into this magnificent team. Losing him for a superior rugby player would be an incredible blow. We should be grateful for Hartley and not consider such foolishness.Mellsblue wrote:It's a question a lot of people have been asking for just over a year. The answer is beyond me. I'm sure it'll happen in time and it's one of the ones that will have to happen for us to win the World Cup.Stom wrote:Without going into it in detail, I just have one comment:
How the hell is Hartley ahead of George! That guy is insane. Runs 5 times more per game than Hartley, makes more tackles, misses fewer, concedes fewer penalties...