RugbyRebels

kk67 wrote:

Stones of granite wrote: If you want to start a fucking spangly-arsed discussion about the "evils of profit", start a new thread.

No need. That is the total goal of all wars.

Stones of granite wrote:

kk67 wrote:

Stones of granite wrote: If you want to start a fucking spangly-arsed discussion about the "evils of profit", start a new thread.

No need. That is the total goal of all wars.

Are you now describing this as a war?

Donny osmond wrote:

Stones of granite wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:Its hard to see how the Spanish govt could have handled this worse, tbh. That being said, a declaration of independence from Barcelona would be comically inept also; Spain would permanently veto their entry into the EU, or at least make it very very expensive, as would any other EU country with a separatist movement. If popular opinion was 95% pro indy they might be able to swing it, and Spain appears to be trying its hardest to get that figure up there, but for now its a foolish move for the Catalans to make and one which would possibly backfire just as spectacularly as the Spanish actions of recent days.

Well, it's dead simple. The Catalans would be taking back control. All they have to do is form a strong and stable Government, and then they will be free to make trade deals with the rest of the world.

Donny osmond wrote: What I dont get, given the massive economic and political impact it will have on the lives of everyone in Spain who doesnt live in Catalonia, why is it only a decision for the Catalan people? How is splitting up a country only a decision for a select few? Surely every Spanish person should have a say on the future of Spain? Or am I misunderstanding the concept of democracy?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Dead right. Ghandi should have held an Empire-wide poll before requesting independence from the Empire. Undemocratic bastard.

Not if the rest of the world doesnt recognize their act as a legal one, and its hard to think of a reason they would.

Reductio ad absurdum, as you're fond of pointing out.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

kk67 wrote:

Stones of granite wrote:

kk67 wrote:
No need. That is the total goal of all wars.

Are you now describing this as a war?

I hope not. But all conflict is profit driven.
Simple fact.

kk67 wrote:
Are we going to continue to classify global progress by profit....?. Surely this is the moment to forget that self-fulfilling bollocks.

Stones of granite wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

Stones of granite wrote: Well, it's dead simple. The Catalans would be taking back control. All they have to do is form a strong and stable Government, and then they will be free to make trade deals with the rest of the world.


Dead right. Ghandi should have held an Empire-wide poll before requesting independence from the Empire. Undemocratic bastard.

Not if the rest of the world doesnt recognize their act as a legal one, and its hard to think of a reason they would.

Reductio ad absurdum, as you're fond of pointing out.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

True, Puigdemont and his buddies need to assess how big a risk that is. In reality there are plenty countries that be contrarian just for shits and giggles, and try to piss off the EU.
I wouldn't be surprised if we were one of them.

Donny osmond wrote:Its hard to see how the Spanish govt could have handled this worse, tbh. That being said, a declaration of independence from Barcelona would be comically inept also; Spain would permanently veto their entry into the EU, or at least make it very very expensive, as would any other EU country with a separatist movement. If popular opinion was 95% pro indy they might be able to swing it, and Spain appears to be trying its hardest to get that figure up there, but for now its a foolish move for the Catalans to make and one which would possibly backfire just as spectacularly as the Spanish actions of recent days.

What I dont get, given the massive economic and political impact it will have on the lives of everyone in Spain who doesnt live in Catalonia, why is it only a decision for the Catalan people? How is splitting up a country only a decision for a select few? Surely every Spanish person should have a say on the future of Spain? Or am I misunderstanding the concept of democracy?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

OptimisticJock wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:Its hard to see how the Spanish govt could have handled this worse, tbh. That being said, a declaration of independence from Barcelona would be comically inept also; Spain would permanently veto their entry into the EU, or at least make it very very expensive, as would any other EU country with a separatist movement. If popular opinion was 95% pro indy they might be able to swing it, and Spain appears to be trying its hardest to get that figure up there, but for now its a foolish move for the Catalans to make and one which would possibly backfire just as spectacularly as the Spanish actions of recent days.

What I dont get, given the massive economic and political impact it will have on the lives of everyone in Spain who doesnt live in Catalonia, why is it only a decision for the Catalan people? How is splitting up a country only a decision for a select few? Surely every Spanish person should have a say on the future of Spain? Or am I misunderstanding the concept of democracy?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I disagree with you here. I don't see why a people that see themselves as distinctly different should be forced to remain a part of a country they don't feel an affinity to just because others want them (or more appropriately their money).

Donny osmond wrote:

OptimisticJock wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:Its hard to see how the Spanish govt could have handled this worse, tbh. That being said, a declaration of independence from Barcelona would be comically inept also; Spain would permanently veto their entry into the EU, or at least make it very very expensive, as would any other EU country with a separatist movement. If popular opinion was 95% pro indy they might be able to swing it, and Spain appears to be trying its hardest to get that figure up there, but for now its a foolish move for the Catalans to make and one which would possibly backfire just as spectacularly as the Spanish actions of recent days.

What I dont get, given the massive economic and political impact it will have on the lives of everyone in Spain who doesnt live in Catalonia, why is it only a decision for the Catalan people? How is splitting up a country only a decision for a select few? Surely every Spanish person should have a say on the future of Spain? Or am I misunderstanding the concept of democracy?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I disagree with you here. I don't see why a people that see themselves as distinctly different should be forced to remain a part of a country they don't feel an affinity to just because others want them (or more appropriately their money).

I agree with you there but I think its only one side of the coin. The rest of Spain will be massively effected by Catalan independence. Telling 10s of millions of Spanish people that their economic and political lives are in for an earthquake, based on the will of a couple of million Catalans, and they what they think about that doesnt matter a damn... strikes me as a pretty dubious version of democracy.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

OptimisticJock wrote: I disagree with you here. I don't see why a people that see themselves as distinctly different should be forced to remain a part of a country they don't feel an affinity to just because others want them (or more appropriately their money).

I agree with you there but I think its only one side of the coin. The rest of Spain will be massively effected by Catalan independence. Telling 10s of millions of Spanish people that their economic and political lives are in for an earthquake, based on the will of a couple of million Catalans, and they what they think about that doesnt matter a damn... strikes me as a pretty dubious version of democracy.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

EU will be affected by brexit. They should have had a vote in our referendum. Same logic.

Donny osmond wrote:

OptimisticJock wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:Its hard to see how the Spanish govt could have handled this worse, tbh. That being said, a declaration of independence from Barcelona would be comically inept also; Spain would permanently veto their entry into the EU, or at least make it very very expensive, as would any other EU country with a separatist movement. If popular opinion was 95% pro indy they might be able to swing it, and Spain appears to be trying its hardest to get that figure up there, but for now its a foolish move for the Catalans to make and one which would possibly backfire just as spectacularly as the Spanish actions of recent days.

What I dont get, given the massive economic and political impact it will have on the lives of everyone in Spain who doesnt live in Catalonia, why is it only a decision for the Catalan people? How is splitting up a country only a decision for a select few? Surely every Spanish person should have a say on the future of Spain? Or am I misunderstanding the concept of democracy?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I disagree with you here. I don't see why a people that see themselves as distinctly different should be forced to remain a part of a country they don't feel an affinity to just because others want them (or more appropriately their money).

I agree with you there but I think its only one side of the coin. The rest of Spain will be massively effected by Catalan independence. Telling 10s of millions of Spanish people that their economic and political lives are in for an earthquake, based on the will of a couple of million Catalans, and they what they think about that doesnt matter a damn... strikes me as a pretty dubious version of democracy.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Which Tyler wrote:Please explain the difference then.

Why is Catalan independence from Spain so different from Scottish independence from Britain, or British independence from the EU?

The similarities are self-evident - a subsect feels different, and wants to separate from the whole; geo-political boundaries already established.

OptimisticJock wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

OptimisticJock wrote: I disagree with you here. I don't see why a people that see themselves as distinctly different should be forced to remain a part of a country they don't feel an affinity to just because others want them (or more appropriately their money).

I agree with you there but I think its only one side of the coin. The rest of Spain will be massively effected by Catalan independence. Telling 10s of millions of Spanish people that their economic and political lives are in for an earthquake, based on the will of a couple of million Catalans, and they what they think about that doesnt matter a damn... strikes me as a pretty dubious version of democracy.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I'd say it's undemocratic to deny a subsection of a country it's right to independence because others don't like it.

Donny osmond wrote:

Which Tyler wrote:Please explain the difference then.

Why is Catalan independence from Spain so different from Scottish independence from Britain, or British independence from the EU?

The similarities are self-evident - a subsect feels different, and wants to separate from the whole; geo-political boundaries already established.

Membership of the EU is voluntary and always been. Hence why there's an article 50, if anyone wants to leave they can. I'm no expert (no, really) but can anyone name a country that has written into its constitution/legal framework that any part of the country can just bugger off whenever they feel like without consideration of what the rest of the county thinks? That's not how countries work, or at least not how they're supposed to work.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

Which Tyler wrote:Please explain the difference then.

Why is Catalan independence from Spain so different from Scottish independence from Britain, or British independence from the EU?

The similarities are self-evident - a subsect feels different, and wants to separate from the whole; geo-political boundaries already established.

Membership of the EU is voluntary and always been. Hence why there's an article 50, if anyone wants to leave they can. I'm no expert (no, really) but can anyone name a country that has written into its constitution/legal framework that any part of the country can just bugger off whenever they feel like without consideration of what the rest of the county thinks? That's not how countries work, or at least not how they're supposed to work.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Liechtenstein... is the funniest example.

And if looking only within Europe, then Denmark, Netherlands, France all have some form of provision that give provinces the right to self-determination.

Donny osmond wrote:

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote: Membership of the EU is voluntary and always been. Hence why there's an article 50, if anyone wants to leave they can. I'm no expert (no, really) but can anyone name a country that has written into its constitution/legal framework that any part of the country can just bugger off whenever they feel like without consideration of what the rest of the county thinks? That's not how countries work, or at least not how they're supposed to work.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Liechtenstein... is the funniest example.

And if looking only within Europe, then Denmark, Netherlands, France all have some form of provision that give provinces the right to self-determination.

Self determination or full independence?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

Zhivago wrote:
Liechtenstein... is the funniest example.

And if looking only within Europe, then Denmark, Netherlands, France all have some form of provision that give provinces the right to self-determination.

Self determination or full independence?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I'm not answering stupid questions

Donny osmond wrote:

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote: Self determination or full independence?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

I'm not answering stupid questions

Because you can't?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Zhivago wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

Zhivago wrote:
I'm not answering stupid questions

Because you can't?

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

That must be the reason. Totally not because I don't care enough to try to wrangle out whatever it is you mean by your question. If you're interested in the details of the cases I mentioned, I suggest you Google it.

bruce wrote:Similar to the Basque country, doesn't Catalonia incorporate a bit of France? Or is my geography all to shit.

Donny osmond wrote:

Which Tyler wrote:Please explain the difference then.

Why is Catalan independence from Spain so different from Scottish independence from Britain, or British independence from the EU?

The similarities are self-evident - a subsect feels different, and wants to separate from the whole; geo-political boundaries already established.

Membership of the EU is voluntary and always been. Hence why there's an article 50, if anyone wants to leave they can. I'm no expert (no, really) but can anyone name a country that has written into its constitution/legal framework that any part of the country can just bugger off whenever they feel like without consideration of what the rest of the county thinks? That's not how countries work, or at least not how they're supposed to work.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

Stones of granite wrote:

Donny osmond wrote:

Which Tyler wrote:Please explain the difference then.

Why is Catalan independence from Spain so different from Scottish independence from Britain, or British independence from the EU?

The similarities are self-evident - a subsect feels different, and wants to separate from the whole; geo-political boundaries already established.

Membership of the EU is voluntary and always been. Hence why there's an article 50, if anyone wants to leave they can. I'm no expert (no, really) but can anyone name a country that has written into its constitution/legal framework that any part of the country can just bugger off whenever they feel like without consideration of what the rest of the county thinks? That's not how countries work, or at least not how they're supposed to work.

Sent from my HUAWEI VNS-L31 using Tapatalk

You seem to be backtracking a bit Donny. If I remember correctly, following the Scotland Referendum, you claimed it ironic that Nationalists wanted to leave the UK Union but remain part of the European Union. Now you are differentiating them.

If this wasn't you, I apologise, but it was certainly someone here.