Page 2 of 2

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 1:53 pm
by Puja
Minute 71: Japan take one phase to the middle of the park, before passing it back for the fly-half to kick long. It's a shocking kick - straight down FSmith's throat in the middle of the park and he immediately feeds Furbank to go on an adventure. He rounds the first chaser, draws in the second and passes away before contact to set Slade free down the wing. He is hauled in by the cover defence, but steps inside and takes contact on his own terms for quick ruck ball. We take two forward phases with good clearing and Randall sweeping the ball away off the deck in crisp, accurate service, before going to the backs.

FSmith carries and shows the ball to the close runners to interest the Japanese defence, before putting a long pass over the top to Roebuck. The debutant accelerates onto it, then pulls a ridiculous double sidestep and turn on the burners to go inside one player and outside the covering defence. He beats his opposite man and three covering tacklers in the space of 5m - superb. He considers taking on Yamagawa on the outside, but he'd likely have to muscle through a tackle and the chances of making it all the way to the line without going into touch are 50:50 at best, so he instead steps back inside to keep the ball alive.

As he's tackled, Underhill calls for the pop pass which Roebuck delivers on a plate and was probably a scoring pass, but unfortunately the a Japanese player gets a hand in and just interferes enough to rip the ball loose from his grasp. Crying shame.

Minute 72: The referee was actually playing advantage for Japan not getting back onside after our quick phases of possession, so we come back for the penalty on the 10m line (which does again feel generous after a try-scoring chance, especially if it was going to be an England scrum for the knock-on, but hey ho). Slade kicks down for a lineout just inside the 22 (or about 10m back from where Roebuck got to). Not the most active of minutes this one.

Minute 73: England throw to the front and set up a maul - it's a bit dishevelled as Dan has to spend several seconds searching for the ball before getting into the driver's seat at the back. We then don't appear interested in pushing - there is a definite lack of leg movement there.

Dan breaks away from the back and offers the pass to our "inside centre" on the crash ball, before carrying it into contact himself. Earl forgets his new role and picks and goes from the quick ruck ball to stress the Japanese defence some more - it'd be a good move, but unfortunately, Michael Leitch's knee said something unforgiveable about Ewels's mother and events ensued the only way they could.

The ref originally calls it as "diving off feet and from the side" which is a decent spot given how many of those aren't given in a game. He has in general had an excellent game - I'd be happy to see him reffing us again. The TMO is the one who chimes in to call the dangerous play and we take some time of staring at screens and deliberating. Looking at the offence in slow motion, I stand by my opinion that it's clumsy, reckless, dangerous, but not deliberate.

Minute 74: Interesting situation - Japan kicked for touch from the penalty when it was just "off feet", but there's a big long gap and the officials have all gathered together to look at the screen, so when time back on is called, the ref signals the penalty again and Matsuda gets to do the kick for touch again. I don't think he actually does as well second time as he did the first!

Ewels was originally sat down on the England bench with the substitutes, but apparently there is a separate plastic garden chair of shame for those in the sin-bin/waiting on bunker and the 4th official moves him over to sit on his own like he's being punished for talking in class.

Japan take the lineout in the middle and go off the top (with some more excellent hands from Dearns) to spin into midfield immediately. They go through a couple of phases without stressing the English defence before it goes back to Matsuda to kick up in the air again. Again, it's a terrible kick - this one drifting into touch on the full.

Minute 75: We take the lineout with TCurry jumping at the front, and set up a maul that we have a brief drive at, but nothing too energetic. The ball is presented to Randall and passed away to our "12" running hard at first receiver. He's fine - can't really see a massive difference in play between that and Lawrence, but then I still maintain that carrying the crash ball isn't the best use of Lawrence anyway and it's not like we don't send our number 8 on those runs from time to time.

We go again with a forward runner off Randall, before FSmith jacks to the blind-side, creating an overlap. Randall gives him the ball and he takes it to the line before putting Earl through a hole on his shoulder. Japan haul him down eventually, but we're into the 22 with quick ball. Another phase on the blind, before Randall plays it open to the forward runners. England run two nice phases with a forward tipping on to a carrier, before we go out to the backs again.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 2:25 pm
by Puja
Minute 76: Furbank pulls back to FSmith who puts a grubber through for Roebuck to chase - I think I'd've preferred he kept it in hand, but it's far from a KADAB as it rolls into the space behind Nezuka and he only just manages to regain it and avoid being carried over his own line. Japan just about hold onto possession, but they're right on the edge of their tryline and the only option is to pass back to the 10 and let him scramble a clearance kick for an England lineout 8m out.

Unfortunately, we then cock it up by ignoring the ref when he calls, "Blue, no huddle" and getting a free-kick against us. Seems a bit harsh, cause he's been letting us get away with fannying about there all game, but perhaps he'd had a word with us a few minutes ago? Anyway, Japan free-kick, which they unsurprisingly tap and run. It's still not a great decision or execution - our defence is set and, instead of a pressure-free kick for touch to get them up the pitch, Naikabula unsuccessfully tries to bulldoze FSmith and, when he hits the deck, Underhill is locked in over the ball for an England penalty.

Minute 77: FSmith puts the ball in the corner and, in fairness to the ref, England do get the hell on with it without a huddle. Once again, it's front ball for TCurry and we got for the charge into a maul that Japan disrupted with sacking twice earlier in the game. They don't read it this time and we rumble forwards at pace. Dan tries to scrape the ball to the back, but Underhill tells him to get knotted and bursts over the line himself.

Minute 78: Slade kicks the conversion - he's a good kicker, but I'm surprised that he's ahead of giving FSmith more experience at international level.

Minute 79: Ewels is upgraded to a red card and we get to watch replays and see him sitting on his garden chair of shame, instead of watching the rugby that's actively happening. Thanks RugbyPass!

When we come back, it's a Japan lineout about 35m out. They throw it to the middle and Martin does enough to force a loose ball. It bounces kindly for Japan and they manage to scramble possession back. They run a few phases, but it's just breaking against our defence without trouble.

Minute 80: Curry makes a good low tackle and Marler is in to turn the ball back to our side. Earl plays 9 and feeds to Dan on the run - it's a 4-on-0 and Roebuck should be given the ball and away, but Dan juggles the ball and ruins the overlap, then tries stepping back inside and slips over. Not his best 10 seconds on a rugby pitch.

Randall sets up a caterpillar and box-kick and this one is... better, although still not perfect as it only goes 15m forward. It's contestable though and Roebuck slaps it back. The ball is passed to FSmith in midfield - Japan have numbers out wide and there's nothing much on, so he puts in a low rolling kick towards the corner. It's not got enough on it to threaten a 50:22, but it does force Yamasawa to chase back into his 22 and face the England kick-chase alone. He opts to run instead of kick and, not for the first time, Japan's commitment to their theme is their undoing as he's unceremoniously dumped into touch by Furbank.

Minute 81: The lineout is straight-esque and goes to Itoje in the middle. We feign a maul and then play away, passing out to Earl on the run, who then passes to Lawrence on the run for a double-faux-12 whammy. Works nicely - quick ball and over the gainline. Randall sweeps it away off the deck for two forwards phases again, but the second one this time sees Martin break the first tackle, commit a second man and then throw an absolutely outrageous back of the hand offload out of the tackle, which surprised me so much on first watching that I originally thought it was a Japanese rip that landed luckily, rather than a pass. Furbank runs onto it and only Osada's quick reactions stop him from going through for a try. England's support is there quickly and we get lightning quick ball again. Once again, I might've been happier with FSmith keeping the ball in hand, as we do have an overlap and could probably get it through the hands, but on the other hand, his chip over the top very nearly makes a try. It lands just ahead of Lawrence - if we have an actual winger out there, he probably gets there quickly enough to take it on the full or, if the winger is Jack Nowell, he waits for the bounce and takes his time to gather and walk over. Lawrence makes the wrong choice to go for the diving catch, which was a long-shot at best, and ends up knocking it on for the end of the game.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 2:34 pm
by Puja
So, off the initial impressions:

We did indeed slip off too many tackles and made Japan look better than they were - 11 egregious ones that I counted, although notable that only three of them were in the second half. Mind, two of them were what created the first Japan try.

Our rush defence did seem less aggressive than it was in the 6N - possibly a function of the heat and possibly adapting to the opposition.

6 stupid penalties, although again only 2 in the second half.

IFW, Itoje, Underhill, George were all superb. Mitchell and Randall were good - the box-kicking for the latter obviously an issue, but his fast service from the base of the ruck was reminiscent of Aaron Smith and is just the kind of thing I want from a 9.

Rodd wasn't great, but wasn't as bad as I originally thought. Dan was massively disappointing and, looking at the nuts and bolts work that George does, along with the lineout accuracy, unlines why he's still starting.

Earl was fine as a 12, but mostly he just did the same things he would've done at 8. Well nigh impossible to judge in a game that loose, against a knackered and low-level opponent.

Overall, we were rusty in places and made a lot of mistakes and, if we turn in that performance against New Zealand, we'll get annihilated. However, there was more than enough there to see that we're building something and more than enough hope that that game knocked the rust off and we'll be firing by the time we get on the pitch in Dunedin. Feeling oddly hopeful for the first test, which is unusual when touring NZ.

Puja

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 2:45 pm
by Which Tyler
Puja wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 12:50 pm Minute 66: More reinforcements - the sin-bin is up, so FSmith comes on in place of MSmith's return and Freeman is rewarded for his excellent play by being replaced by Ewels. I didn't actually realise that Earl had been moved to the centre when watching this live; I had assumed that one of the back row had gone off, so I'm interested to see if he was any good there in this review. I'm assuming Slade's going onto the wing? Not the fastest option, but who else would it be?
Pretty sure I spotted Freeman rolling on the ground holding his lower leg in the corner of a shot, a minute or two before going off.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 3:25 pm
by pjm1
Fantastic commentary as always, thank you Puja. Fired over a little something so you can get yourself a birthday pint :)

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 5:13 pm
by Puja
pjm1 wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 3:25 pm Fantastic commentary as always, thank you Puja. Fired over a little something so you can get yourself a birthday pint :)
Thank you. That's really kind!

Puja

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 7:08 pm
by Puja
Which Tyler wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 2:45 pm
Puja wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 12:50 pm Minute 66: More reinforcements - the sin-bin is up, so FSmith comes on in place of MSmith's return and Freeman is rewarded for his excellent play by being replaced by Ewels. I didn't actually realise that Earl had been moved to the centre when watching this live; I had assumed that one of the back row had gone off, so I'm interested to see if he was any good there in this review. I'm assuming Slade's going onto the wing? Not the fastest option, but who else would it be?
Pretty sure I spotted Freeman rolling on the ground holding his lower leg in the corner of a shot, a minute or two before going off.
That makes a lot of sense. Otherwise surely removing one of Slade/Lawrence would've been the preferred option if you wanted to see whether Twearlve worked.

Puja

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 8:38 pm
by FKAS
I wonder if FSmith is still feeling the knock from the final a bit hence the no restarts or points kicking.

Randall seems to fit our new attacking style, Wigglesworth is probably being charged with sorting out his kicking just he did with Mitchell's last summer.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 9:10 pm
by Mikey Brown
IWWT

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Thu Jun 27, 2024 9:51 pm
by Mellsblue
FKAS wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 8:38 pm I wonder if FSmith is still feeling the knock from the final a bit hence the no restarts or points kicking.

Randall seems to fit our new attacking style, Wigglesworth is probably being charged with sorting out his kicking just he did with Mitchell's last summer.
Furbank takes the restarts for Saints and I think did for Eng instead of M. Smith. No idea on pens.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Fri Jun 28, 2024 7:45 am
by FKAS
Mellsblue wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 9:51 pm
FKAS wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 8:38 pm I wonder if FSmith is still feeling the knock from the final a bit hence the no restarts or points kicking.

Randall seems to fit our new attacking style, Wigglesworth is probably being charged with sorting out his kicking just he did with Mitchell's last summer.
Furbank takes the restarts for Saints and I think did for Eng instead of M. Smith. No idea on pens.
Fin's an exceptional goal kicker. Can't say I'd noticed Furbank taking restarts for Saints but he's a good kicker so would make sense.

Hopefully he's fine to provide back up next weekend.

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Fri Jun 28, 2024 8:25 am
by Puja
FKAS wrote: Fri Jun 28, 2024 7:45 am
Mellsblue wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 9:51 pm
FKAS wrote: Thu Jun 27, 2024 8:38 pm I wonder if FSmith is still feeling the knock from the final a bit hence the no restarts or points kicking.

Randall seems to fit our new attacking style, Wigglesworth is probably being charged with sorting out his kicking just he did with Mitchell's last summer.
Furbank takes the restarts for Saints and I think did for Eng instead of M. Smith. No idea on pens.
Fin's an exceptional goal kicker. Can't say I'd noticed Furbank taking restarts for Saints but he's a good kicker so would make sense.

Hopefully he's fine to provide back up next weekend.
I mean, Slade's turned into an absolutely belting kicker as well, so we're not short on options.

Puja

Re: Japan vs England - minute-by-minute

Posted: Sun Jun 30, 2024 6:37 pm
by Greebo
Thanks for all your efforts, much appreciated.