Williams 5
James 6
North 7+1 for the try
J Davies 6
Roberts 8.5+1 for the try
Biggar 6
G Davies 4+1 for the try
Evans 8
Baldwin 8-1 for butterfingers
Lee 8
Clart 7
AWJ 5+1 for the steal
Warbs 6
Tips 6
Faletau 9
Ratings
Moderator: Sandydragon
- UKHamlet
- Site Admin
- Posts: 1450
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 3:07 pm
- Location: Swansea
- Contact:
- glamorganmorgan
- Posts: 62
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 4:32 pm
Re: Ratings
Williams 5 (lucky to get it)
James 6 ish
North 8
J Davies 6 but missed at least 1 tackle
Roberts 9 but ............one dimentional can he pass?
Biggar 7
G Davies 6 (heads down rugby)
Evans 8 ish
Baldwin 7 (Butterfs)
Lee 8
Clart 8
Awj 6+!
Warbs 5 +2 when Lydiate came on
Tips 5 who was knocked off the ball continuously
Faletau 9
I would also like to say that the whole performance improved when the subs came on
James 6 ish
North 8
J Davies 6 but missed at least 1 tackle
Roberts 9 but ............one dimentional can he pass?
Biggar 7
G Davies 6 (heads down rugby)
Evans 8 ish
Baldwin 7 (Butterfs)
Lee 8
Clart 8
Awj 6+!
Warbs 5 +2 when Lydiate came on
Tips 5 who was knocked off the ball continuously
Faletau 9
I would also like to say that the whole performance improved when the subs came on
- Sourdust
- Posts: 817
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 5:03 pm
- Contact:
Re: Ratings
Sanjay 5 - Seemed fairly anonymous.
James 6 - Got involved where he could, but too slow when it mattered.
North 8 - Please let him be back for good...
Foxy 6 - Meh.
Dr 8 (+1) - I saw him throw a pass!
Biggar 6 (+1) - Adjusted for playing on one leg.
Davies 6 - Great finish but pedestrian otherwise.
Evans 8 - Never saw him but the scrum went well...
Baldwin 7 - Not as prominent as usual but basics good enough.
Lee 8 - Never saw him but the scrum went well...
Luke 8 - Having him in a maul is like going snorkeling with a shark-eating robot.
AWJ 5 (+2) - Was he AWOL? Adjusted for sheer disbelief...
Warbs 6 - No, he isn't.
Tips 6 - Turned up.
Faletau 10 (-1) - Adjusted because that's just silly.
James 6 - Got involved where he could, but too slow when it mattered.
North 8 - Please let him be back for good...
Foxy 6 - Meh.
Dr 8 (+1) - I saw him throw a pass!
Biggar 6 (+1) - Adjusted for playing on one leg.
Davies 6 - Great finish but pedestrian otherwise.
Evans 8 - Never saw him but the scrum went well...
Baldwin 7 - Not as prominent as usual but basics good enough.
Lee 8 - Never saw him but the scrum went well...
Luke 8 - Having him in a maul is like going snorkeling with a shark-eating robot.
AWJ 5 (+2) - Was he AWOL? Adjusted for sheer disbelief...
Warbs 6 - No, he isn't.
Tips 6 - Turned up.
Faletau 10 (-1) - Adjusted because that's just silly.
-
- Posts: 723
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 11:12 pm
Re: Ratings
How can that many players get an 8 or above and Wales still look completely off the boil for ~60 minutes?
- Billyfish
- Posts: 312
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:33 pm
Re: Ratings
5ish for everyone I'd have thought, bar Talupe and Dr Bob and the front row praps. Still quite a flat performance.
Gerald Davies, what was he doing there?!
- Sandydragon
- Posts: 10473
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:13 pm
Re: Ratings
Lots of 5s and 6s for me except Roberts, North and Faletau who I'd for for an 8 with a 7 for the front row.
Perhaps abut harsh but for long period in that game we didn't look like we were contenders.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Perhaps abut harsh but for long period in that game we didn't look like we were contenders.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk