EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Moderator: Puja
-
- Posts: 5925
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Chisholm is a good player but I’m not sure he’s a better option than Morgan.
With noting Eddie was at the Gloucester game last week so will have seen Morgan playing well. Surely without Billy, Hughes and Simmonds he’s at least worth a squad place at least.
I suspect Eddie will be tempted to go with players he knows but a specialist always beats a player out of position IMO so as much as I like Wilson, I hope he’s considered as a 6 rather than a makeshift 8.
TBH, I wouldn’t be at all surprised to see Shields at 8.
With noting Eddie was at the Gloucester game last week so will have seen Morgan playing well. Surely without Billy, Hughes and Simmonds he’s at least worth a squad place at least.
I suspect Eddie will be tempted to go with players he knows but a specialist always beats a player out of position IMO so as much as I like Wilson, I hope he’s considered as a 6 rather than a makeshift 8.
TBH, I wouldn’t be at all surprised to see Shields at 8.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Similar in that we're expecting others will shift towards us when they've little incentive, or ignoring if they don't it hurts us. I agree we're closer to the laws and stated interpretationsPuja wrote:Not really - in this one, we're following what the IRB are saying and doing as we're told.Digby wrote:Our position is akin to the Moggy telling the EU they could change to match us, yes they could, but they aren't and we're hurting ourselves in the processPuja wrote:
The AP refs are currently closest to the IRB's clarifications and declarations on the laws. Without wishing to sound like Jacob Rees-Mogg, it's the foreigners who need to change to match what we're doing.
Puja
Puja
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Given how Eddie has set us up so far Rhodes is nailed on
-
- Posts: 1536
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:31 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
It's not that long ago we were all agreeing that we had ridiculous strength in depth at LH. We're gonna find out now.fivepointer wrote:Moon is a real option at LH. I'd also add in Catt. Both are dependable scrummagers. Ideally VRR will get a call but you never know with Eddie.
Mercer should be next in line based on the previous squad but Morgan would offer some experience. The only other 8 who might get a call is Chisholm.
These are all good players but we would be down to 4/5 choices in 2 key positions.
-
- Posts: 5925
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
This is true. Unfortunately, very few of those mentioned actually have caps.
In a way, we’ve been fairly lucky to have had such a long run in which we’ve pretty much always had two of Mako, Marler and Genge available.
The downside of that is that the alternatives have very few caps between them.
Mullan has a few caps but has been injured for a while and isn’t really someone I’d expect to be challenging for the World Cup squad. Hepburn has a couple of substitute appearances and then none of the others have any at all.
Catt and Moon have plenty of overall experience and are probably more direct replacements for Marler, but VRR is a strong scrummager who offers more outside of the set piece in terms of carrying and breakdown work.
In a way, we’ve been fairly lucky to have had such a long run in which we’ve pretty much always had two of Mako, Marler and Genge available.
The downside of that is that the alternatives have very few caps between them.
Mullan has a few caps but has been injured for a while and isn’t really someone I’d expect to be challenging for the World Cup squad. Hepburn has a couple of substitute appearances and then none of the others have any at all.
Catt and Moon have plenty of overall experience and are probably more direct replacements for Marler, but VRR is a strong scrummager who offers more outside of the set piece in terms of carrying and breakdown work.
-
- Posts: 1972
- Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2017 9:41 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
It's pretty nuclear for us to have had 2 LHs (Genge being out for some time) and 2/3 no. 8s to have gone down in what, three weeks? I hold very little hope for the AIs and just a smidgen of faith that the extension of the losing habit that I now expect to continue , won't continue to haunt us into 2019
To echo others, Morgan has to come back, with Mercer, surely. But then again Robshaw has covered there for the odd half and Tom Wood, Haskell and a couple of former, barely tested, kiwis are fit.
None of the LH options are especially appealing tbh given how long Mako and Marler have held court there.
Wtf happens at lock? A broken nose (Itoje) could be 5 weeks if it's aggravated enough, so no Launch, Lawes, Itoje and Kruis has only been 'solid' to me - which is fine and even welcome, but needs... Something.
Another concern is that the enforced changes will reduce wriggle room elsewhere, so we can look forward to Hartley, Cole, Haskell, Brown regaining/solidifying their grasps.
Think I might see if being Irish suits for a couple of years.
To echo others, Morgan has to come back, with Mercer, surely. But then again Robshaw has covered there for the odd half and Tom Wood, Haskell and a couple of former, barely tested, kiwis are fit.
None of the LH options are especially appealing tbh given how long Mako and Marler have held court there.
Wtf happens at lock? A broken nose (Itoje) could be 5 weeks if it's aggravated enough, so no Launch, Lawes, Itoje and Kruis has only been 'solid' to me - which is fine and even welcome, but needs... Something.
Another concern is that the enforced changes will reduce wriggle room elsewhere, so we can look forward to Hartley, Cole, Haskell, Brown regaining/solidifying their grasps.
Think I might see if being Irish suits for a couple of years.
Last edited by Danno on Mon Oct 15, 2018 10:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
-
- Posts: 5925
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Lawes’ injury isn’t serious AFAIK. A back spasm IIRC? Hopefully Itoje and George’s broken noses aren’t overly serious.
I don’t think Cole is likely to be selected.
Who knows what Eddie will do?
If the outcome is recalls for the likes of Morgan and Attwood and first caps for VRR, there could be some form of silver lining.
I don’t think Cole is likely to be selected.
Who knows what Eddie will do?
If the outcome is recalls for the likes of Morgan and Attwood and first caps for VRR, there could be some form of silver lining.
-
- Posts: 1972
- Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2017 9:41 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
That's quite soothing. Maybe you should force the RFU to employ you as EJs spokesman for the next year+5 weeks
- Puja
- Posts: 17746
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
If you listen to Andrew Bridgen, you can become Irish on the spur of the moment.Danno wrote:It's pretty nuclear for us to have had 2 LHs (Genge being out for some time) and 2/3 no. 8s to have gone down in what, three weeks? I hold very little hope for the AIs and just a smidgen of faith that the extension of the losing habit that I now expect to continue , won't continue to haunt us into 2019
To echo others, Morgan has to come back, with Mercer, surely. But then again Robshaw has covered there for the odd half and Tom Wood, Haskell and a couple of former, barely tested, kiwis are fit.
None of the LH options are especially appealing tbh given how long Mako and Marler have held court there.
Wtf happens at lock? A broken nose (Itoje) could be 5 weeks if it's aggravated enough, so no Launch, Lawes, Itoje and Kruis has only been 'solid' to me - which is fine and even welcome, but needs... Something.
Another concern is that the enforced changes will reduce wriggle room elsewhere, so we can look forward to Hartley, Cole, Haskell, Brown regaining/solidifying their grasps.
Think I might see if being Irish suits for a couple of years.
Puja
Backist Monk
- Adam_P
- Posts: 1780
- Joined: Fri Feb 26, 2016 11:14 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Lawes reckons he'll be back next week, it's a minor back spasm
-
- Posts: 5925
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
I’ll take the job, provided I’m allowed to pick the side too. I’ll even open it up to the window of Rugby Rebels’ panel of selectors. Where do I apply?Danno wrote:That's quite soothing. Maybe you should force the RFU to employ you as EJs spokesman for the next year+5 weeks
-
- Posts: 1536
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:31 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
I'd like to VRR and Hepburn getting some gametime but I'm not sure Eddie rates VRR to start with. Also I haven't actually seen VRR play yet this season so it's guesswork on my part. I'm also not sure Cole's been written off by Eddie yet, especially considering what's happening at LH.
- Mellsblue
- Posts: 15766
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Just pop down to The Priory and explain what you’d like to do.Scrumhead wrote:Where do I apply?Danno wrote:That's quite soothing. Maybe you should force the RFU to employ you as EJs spokesman for the next year+5 weeks
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
If we're to recall a Glaws player we haven't seen for a while is Morgan the one to focus on, or should that actually be Twelvetrees?
-
- Posts: 2473
- Joined: Sun Feb 28, 2016 9:05 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Not for me. His performance against Saracens was a big red flag. Looked seriously intimidated by the lack of time an space in that game.Digby wrote:If we're to recall a Glaws player we haven't seen for a while is Morgan the one to focus on, or should that actually be Twelvetrees?
Jonny Williams would be in my squad as one of the 12 options though. Massive talent.
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Fair enough, it's a bit of a brutal standard though where you're out if you look flustered against Sarries, likely we couldn't name 20 never mind 30Timbo wrote:Not for me. His performance against Saracens was a big red flag. Looked seriously intimidated by the lack of time an space in that game.Digby wrote:If we're to recall a Glaws player we haven't seen for a while is Morgan the one to focus on, or should that actually be Twelvetrees?
Jonny Williams would be in my squad as one of the 12 options though. Massive talent.
-
- Posts: 6375
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 3:42 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Unfortunately looking flustered has been Billy's default position in his international appearances. He simply lacks the composure to play effectively at the highest level. great pity as he has all the skills.
The more i see of Williams, the more i think he is a realistic international prospect.
The more i see of Williams, the more i think he is a realistic international prospect.
- Puja
- Posts: 17746
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
He didn't look too clever against Lyon either.Digby wrote:Fair enough, it's a bit of a brutal standard though where you're out if you look flustered against Sarries, likely we couldn't name 20 never mind 30Timbo wrote:Not for me. His performance against Saracens was a big red flag. Looked seriously intimidated by the lack of time an space in that game.Digby wrote:If we're to recall a Glaws player we haven't seen for a while is Morgan the one to focus on, or should that actually be Twelvetrees?
Jonny Williams would be in my squad as one of the 12 options though. Massive talent.
The difference between the two is that Morgan has previously been the business at international level and has shown that he has quality sufficient to manage the step up. Twelvetrees has always flattered to deceive and has never looked a convincing international.
Plus we aren't suffering an injury crisis at centre - we can still call on Fazlet, Slade, Lozowski, Williams, and Manu (for now) at 12.
Puja
Backist Monk
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
I'm flat out not interested in Farrell at 12, and I'd happily contend Twelvetrees has shown more at 12 at test level than both Farrell, Manu and Slade
- Puja
- Posts: 17746
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
I know you're not a Farrell fan, but that's strikingly unfair.Digby wrote:I'm flat out not interested in Farrell at 12, and I'd happily contend Twelvetrees has shown more at 12 at test level than both Farrell, Manu and Slade
Puja
Backist Monk
-
- Posts: 5925
- Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
VRR picked up a shoulder injury and missed a couple of weeks, but was back on the bench last week.Beasties wrote:I'd like to VRR and Hepburn getting some gametime but I'm not sure Eddie rates VRR to start with. Also I haven't actually seen VRR play yet this season so it's guesswork on my part. I'm also not sure Cole's been written off by Eddie yet, especially considering what's happening at LH.
He was excellent at the beginning of the season and was apparently in line for a call-up (heavily rumoured) until the shoulder injury. I think he would have been in instead of Moon had he been available. We’ll find out in a couple of days.
I see what you’re saying about Cole. An inexperienced loosehead would benefit from his experience on the other side of the scrum. However, I think Williams is in the box seat to retain his place with Sinckler offering more as an impact sub.
-
- Posts: 12005
- Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 5:10 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Is it? 12T had some great games, but I don't disagree his temperament had a lot to be desired.Puja wrote:I know you're not a Farrell fan, but that's strikingly unfair.Digby wrote:I'm flat out not interested in Farrell at 12, and I'd happily contend Twelvetrees has shown more at 12 at test level than both Farrell, Manu and Slade
Puja
Did you see Farrell hit the floor with 3 passes in about 5 minutes on Sunday? If Twelvetrees did that people would be calling for a lifetime ban, but nobody even mentioned it when Farrell did it.
- Puja
- Posts: 17746
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
I did see that, all three of them killing promising Saracens attacks. Kinda hoping his knee knock keeps him out of the AIs.Mikey Brown wrote:Is it? 12T had some great games, but I don't disagree his temperament had a lot to be desired.Puja wrote:I know you're not a Farrell fan, but that's strikingly unfair.Digby wrote:I'm flat out not interested in Farrell at 12, and I'd happily contend Twelvetrees has shown more at 12 at test level than both Farrell, Manu and Slade
Puja
Did you see Farrell hit the floor with 3 passes in about 5 minutes on Sunday? If Twelvetrees did that people would be calling for a lifetime ban, but nobody even mentioned it when Farrell did it.
However, that's still not asking a question to which 12T is the answer. If we're going to ditch our 12 who occasionally throws great passes and occasionally passes to the ground, I'd rather not replace him with another. I'm hoping the Glasgow game is a blip, rather than a full blown reversion to 2014 form - Farrell has been playing much better than that over the last year.
Puja
Backist Monk
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Farrell has improved at 10 but not at 12
-
- Posts: 15261
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:17 am
Re: EPS Watch / Player Form Thread
Why?Puja wrote:I know you're not a Farrell fan, but that's strikingly unfair.Digby wrote:I'm flat out not interested in Farrell at 12, and I'd happily contend Twelvetrees has shown more at 12 at test level than both Farrell, Manu and Slade
Puja
Both can pass well, but both make mistakes, with the caveat a large number of Billy's mistakes came late in games where we were playing catchup and he was getting little to no help from attacking talent either side of him such as Farrell and Barritt , and our back row selections were as now limited in supplying fast ball
Both have excellent work rates
Better decision maker is Farrell, but that relates more to the stand off role
Better carrier is Billy
Better tackler is Billy
Better breakdown work comes from Billy
Better kicker is Farrell