Team for Scotland

[Tuco Ramirez]

1 Carre
2 Owens
3 Francis
4 Beard
5 Tshiunza
6 Morgan
7 Reffell
8 Faletau
9 Williams
10 Williams
11 North
12 Hawkins
13 Tompkins
14 Adams
15 Williams

[Buggaluggs]

Don't think I'd drop Dyer. But yeah, need to start looking to the future.

[Sandydragon]

I’d swap North for Dyer. Did nothing wrong whereas North made a lot of mistakes.

[UKHamlet]

I'd drop North for Dyer/LRZ and start Webb.

[Sandydragon]

If LRZ is fit then he has to be back in the team.

[Tuco Ramirez]

Dyer not got a rugby brain

[Son of Mathonwy]

Dyer not got a rugby brain

He had all the pace needed but butchered that try in the first half.

[pompey-zebra]

Dyer not got a rugby brain

He had all the pace needed but butchered that try in the first half.

To be fair to Dyer, he's not the only.one who butchered tries.

[Sandydragon]

Dyer not got a rugby brain

Not as lethal as LRZ but I’d still pick him over North who tends to be anonymous on the wing.

[Son of Mathonwy]

Dyer not got a rugby brain

He had all the pace needed but butchered that try in the first half.

To be fair to Dyer, he's not the only.one who butchered tries.

True but I think Dyer's was the most obvious butchery in the match. Like if a winger with his pace doesn't know what to do to finish that one off....? Real lack of killer instinct.

[Son of Mathonwy]

My team for Scotland:

Thomas
Owens
Francis
Beard
AWJ
Morgan
Reffell
Faletau
Webb
Owen Williams
Adams
Keiran Williams
North
LRZ/Dyer
Liam Williams

Bench: Carre, Lewis, Baldwin, Tshiunza, Tipuric, Webb, Patchell, Hawkins

Tough call over Tips/Reffell. My thinking is (perhaps) that Reffell might be better suited to stealing ball earlier in the match, Tips better at working his rugby magic later in the game.

North wasn't great but we have limited options for 13. Hopefully it was a bad game.

Hopefully Jac will also have a better game next time.

I've yet to be impressed with Dafydd Jenkins, so Tshiunza is in for 2nd row cover (but might get used at 6).

[Ross. S]

AWJ wont play against Scotland after failing a HIA

[pompey-zebra]

He had all the pace needed but butchered that try in the first half.

To be fair to Dyer, he's not the only.one who butchered tries.

True but I think Dyer's was the most obvious butchery in the match. Like if a winger with his pace doesn't know what to do to finish that one off....? Real lack of killer instinct.

Again I'd say singling out a young winger with the least experience in the squad is harsh..there were plenty of orher opportunities to score which weren't taken. Biggar for example.

[pompey-zebra]

He had all the pace needed but butchered that try in the first half.

To be fair to Dyer, he's not the only.one who butchered tries.

True but I think Dyer's was the most obvious butchery in the match. Like if a winger with his pace doesn't know what to do to finish that one off....? Real lack of killer instinct.

Again I'd say singling out a young winger with the least experience in the squad is harsh..there were plenty of orher opportunities to score which weren't taken. Biggar for example.

[Son of Mathonwy]

To be fair to Dyer, he's not the only.one who butchered tries.

True but I think Dyer's was the most obvious butchery in the match. Like if a winger with his pace doesn't know what to do to finish that one off....? Real lack of killer instinct.

Again I'd say singling out a young winger with the least experience in the squad is harsh..there were plenty of orher opportunities to score which weren't taken. Biggar for example.

Maybe. Well I wouldn't drop him, despite that disappointing moment he's better than any other fit winger in the squad.

[Sandydragon]

AWJ wont play against Scotland after failing a HIA

Shame but an opportunity for someone else to stand up.

[Son of Mathonwy]

AWJ wont play against Scotland after failing a HIA

Shame but an opportunity for someone else to stand up.

Mustn't forget Rhys Davies, but I expect Dafydd Jenkins will get a start.

[Sandydragon]

We need to hope the Scots mentally switch off or it could another long afternoon. Englands defence was decidedly poor in places yesterday, but credit to Scotland for a good win at Twickenham.

This is actually the game where Tips could make a real difference. Although I’d still be tempted to start Reffel. I do think this will be a game played at high tempo so we need a pack that can cover the ground.

[MrK]

Williams, Dyer, North, Williams, Adams, Williams, Williams
Carre, Owens, Lewis, Beard, Davies, Morgan, Reffel, Faletau

Roberts, Thomas, Brown, Tshiunza, Wainwright, Webb, Hawkins, Grady

[pompey-zebra]

Williams, Dyer, North, Williams, Adams, Williams, Williams
Carre, Owens, Lewis, Beard, Davies, Morgan, Reffel, Faletau

Roberts, Thomas, Brown, Tshiunza, Wainwright, Webb, Hawkins, Grady

Any other Williams we can get in before Saturday?

[Tuco Ramirez]

Hawkins was good…. See some of you are throwing him under the bus??

[Son of Mathonwy]

Hawkins was good…. See some of you are throwing him under the bus??

Do you think he's been playing better than Keiran Williams for the Ospreys?

[Son of Mathonwy]

Williams, Dyer, North, Williams, Adams, Williams, Williams
Carre, Owens, Lewis, Beard, Davies, Morgan, Reffel, Faletau

Roberts, Thomas, Brown, Tshiunza, Wainwright, Webb, Hawkins, Grady

Love it - it's like an obscure language where the same word can have different meanings depending on its position in the sentence.

[Tuco Ramirez]

Hawkins was good…. See some of you are throwing him under the bus??

Do you think he's been playing better than Keiran Williams for the Ospreys?

I think KW is more prone to a mistake and would get smashed at test level. (Feel free to bookmark)

[Son of Mathonwy]

Hawkins was good…. See some of you are throwing him under the bus??

Do you think he's been playing better than Keiran Williams for the Ospreys?

I think KW is more prone to a mistake and would get smashed at test level. (Feel free to bookmark)

For the KW of last season I might agree but not any more. I'm not saying Hawkins is bad, far from it, but at this moment I think Williams would be more effective. i think Hawkins is excellent for his age rather than plain excellent (which he may well be one day). But if Williams wasn't fit I'd be happy with Hawkins.

I have made a note of your prediction for later use .