That's the crunch bit!Puja wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:57 pmI don't get the fan love for Lawrence at 12. He's looked bang average most times he's played there and his ball security in contact is appalling, which is not a feature you want if you're asking someone to run into contact lots. For all of Tuilagi's many flaws and issues, we can at least send him to crash it up and expect relatively quick ball that consistently comes back on our side. Lawrence might be more likely to make a bust nowadays, but he's also much more likely to get stripped or get held up trying to make an extra metre and result in a 10 second ruck.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:43 pmI think it's all a compromise. Lawrence on the bench is odd. He has to be in case Tuilagi breaks again but it makes more sense to me to start them the other way round. I'd swap Smith and Ford too. Why pick Mitchell to inject pace but start with older/slower players at 10/12. It just seems inconsistent. We have to start well, IMO, to have a chance of winning.
Puja
England vs Argentina
Moderator: Puja
- Oakboy
- Posts: 6397
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am
Re: England vs Argentina
-
- Posts: 8472
- Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2020 4:10 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
And the older centre is slower but more reliably able to crash over the gain line and suck in defenders.Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:56 pmBecause the older 10 is quicker of brain?Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:43 pmI think it's all a compromise. Lawrence on the bench is odd. He has to be in case Tuilagi breaks again but it makes more sense to me to start them the other way round. I'd swap Smith and Ford too. Why pick Mitchell to inject pace but start with older/slower players at 10/12. It just seems inconsistent. We have to start well, IMO, to have a chance of winning.
Hopefully we'll actually use that at some point.
-
- Posts: 8472
- Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2020 4:10 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
He does attack space but he generally attacks it himself and the gets tackled having made only a few metres. He's then out the game and the attack then stumbles through two phases until he's back on his feet.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pmThat's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:56 pmBecause the older 10 is quicker of brain?Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:43 pm
I think it's all a compromise. Lawrence on the bench is odd. He has to be in case Tuilagi breaks again but it makes more sense to me to start them the other way round. I'd swap Smith and Ford too. Why pick Mitchell to inject pace but start with older/slower players at 10/12. It just seems inconsistent. We have to start well, IMO, to have a chance of winning.
At this point on time Smith needs to be one of two playmakers at this level but we don't have one that naturally slots into the backline that can combine well with him.
- Mellsblue
- Posts: 14573
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am
Re: England vs Argentina
You tell me. You’re the one who wants to drop him. I’ll need the context of playing in a dysfunctional team getting murdered at the breakdown, as part of your analysis.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pmThat's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:56 pmBecause the older 10 is quicker of brain?Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:43 pm
I think it's all a compromise. Lawrence on the bench is odd. He has to be in case Tuilagi breaks again but it makes more sense to me to start them the other way round. I'd swap Smith and Ford too. Why pick Mitchell to inject pace but start with older/slower players at 10/12. It just seems inconsistent. We have to start well, IMO, to have a chance of winning.
- Oakboy
- Posts: 6397
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am
Re: England vs Argentina
Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:31 pmYou tell me. You’re the one who wants to drop him. I’ll need the context of playing in a dysfunctional team getting murdered at the breakdown, as part of your analysis.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pmThat's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.

- Oakboy
- Posts: 6397
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am
Re: England vs Argentina
Ah, I get it. You want Farrell at 12 with Smith at 10.FKAS wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:23 pmHe does attack space but he generally attacks it himself and the gets tackled having made only a few metres. He's then out the game and the attack then stumbles through two phases until he's back on his feet.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pmThat's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.
At this point on time Smith needs to be one of two playmakers at this level but we don't have one that naturally slots into the backline that can combine well with him.

-
- Posts: 3828
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Manu, waste of caps now……. However, he is playing alongside his club teammate so that must count for something.
I’d be starting Lawrence.
I’d be starting Lawrence.
-
- Posts: 12180
- Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 5:10 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Well those are our only 2 attacking moves. Smith might manage to dance round someone but I’m going with the consensus on here, even as a huge Smith fan.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:37 pmMellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:31 pmYou tell me. You’re the one who wants to drop him. I’ll need the context of playing in a dysfunctional team getting murdered at the breakdown, as part of your analysis.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pm
That's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.I mainly remember him unsuccessfully trying a grubber kick through a wall of defenders. Apart from that . . . Oh, spiral bombs . . .
I do think Ford has slowed down but he can more reliably get carriers on the front foot in attack, which I think will be more key to us getting back on track. Until we get a handle on the breakdown I don’t think any amount of flair in the backs will make up for it.
- Puja
- Posts: 17743
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
I don't think it is. I didn't watch the Fiji game (was away, thank gods), but the Wales and Ireland games weren't notable for England failing to make initial breaks, but for us then fucking it up and losing possession before we even threatened to score.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:21 pmThat's the crunch bit!Puja wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:57 pmI don't get the fan love for Lawrence at 12. He's looked bang average most times he's played there and his ball security in contact is appalling, which is not a feature you want if you're asking someone to run into contact lots. For all of Tuilagi's many flaws and issues, we can at least send him to crash it up and expect relatively quick ball that consistently comes back on our side. Lawrence might be more likely to make a bust nowadays, but he's also much more likely to get stripped or get held up trying to make an extra metre and result in a 10 second ruck.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 3:43 pm
I think it's all a compromise. Lawrence on the bench is odd. He has to be in case Tuilagi breaks again but it makes more sense to me to start them the other way round. I'd swap Smith and Ford too. Why pick Mitchell to inject pace but start with older/slower players at 10/12. It just seems inconsistent. We have to start well, IMO, to have a chance of winning.
Puja
Puja
Backist Monk
-
- Posts: 8472
- Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2020 4:10 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:39 pmAh, I get it. You want Farrell at 12 with Smith at 10.FKAS wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:23 pmHe does attack space but he generally attacks it himself and the gets tackled having made only a few metres. He's then out the game and the attack then stumbles through two phases until he's back on his feet.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 4:18 pm
That's always been the contention. How many attacking moves has Ford initiated in recent games, though? I think the sharpness of thought has largely been absent with the type of game we are playing. It's just too safety-first. I don't rate Smith that highly but he does at least attack space occasionally.
At this point on time Smith needs to be one of two playmakers at this level but we don't have one that naturally slots into the backline that can combine well with him.![]()

Got to have the Iceman in the team, natural leader etc etc
-
- Posts: 3828
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Really pleased with the side. I believe SB has nailed this. After 4 games testing out options and different game plans he has settled on a starting XV that will bring together the pluses from the one win and 3 defeats.
Strong front row, supported by the most athletic lock pairing to grace this WC. Back row just packs a punch. The mobility and awesome work rate of Lawes compliments the physical 'don't lie down' approach that the too hot to handle Curry brings. An electric 9, maestro 10 and a 12 & 13 combo that can dance or ram their way through a wall of defence whilst keeping the ball alive. It's hard to find a weakness. Should that not be enough we have out wide the 'speedsters', both willing and more than able to run sideways across the pitch to make those game changing 5 metres.
Too much talent? Perhaps. But at 15 we have safety with a capital 'S' and then, to wrap it up, a vocal clappy happy Chappy at 8 to frustrate the opposition and officials.
...... Yes, we can begin to dream.
Strong front row, supported by the most athletic lock pairing to grace this WC. Back row just packs a punch. The mobility and awesome work rate of Lawes compliments the physical 'don't lie down' approach that the too hot to handle Curry brings. An electric 9, maestro 10 and a 12 & 13 combo that can dance or ram their way through a wall of defence whilst keeping the ball alive. It's hard to find a weakness. Should that not be enough we have out wide the 'speedsters', both willing and more than able to run sideways across the pitch to make those game changing 5 metres.
Too much talent? Perhaps. But at 15 we have safety with a capital 'S' and then, to wrap it up, a vocal clappy happy Chappy at 8 to frustrate the opposition and officials.
...... Yes, we can begin to dream.
- Oakboy
- Posts: 6397
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am
Re: England vs Argentina
Have you been on the laughing gas?p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 6:44 pm Really pleased with the side. I believe SB has nailed this. After 4 games testing out options and different game plans he has settled on a starting XV that will bring together the pluses from the one win and 3 defeats.
Strong front row, supported by the most athletic lock pairing to grace this WC. Back row just packs a punch. The mobility and awesome work rate of Lawes compliments the physical 'don't lie down' approach that the too hot to handle Curry brings. An electric 9, maestro 10 and a 12 & 13 combo that can dance or ram their way through a wall of defence whilst keeping the ball alive. It's hard to find a weakness. Should that not be enough we have out wide the 'speedsters', both willing and more than able to run sideways across the pitch to make those game changing 5 metres.
Too much talent? Perhaps. But at 15 we have safety with a capital 'S' and then, to wrap it up, a vocal clappy happy Chappy at 8 to frustrate the opposition and officials.
...... Yes, we can begin to dream.

- Mellsblue
- Posts: 14573
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am
Re: England vs Argentina
Might be the only way to get through it.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 7:13 pmHave you been on the laughing gas?p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 6:44 pm Really pleased with the side. I believe SB has nailed this. After 4 games testing out options and different game plans he has settled on a starting XV that will bring together the pluses from the one win and 3 defeats.
Strong front row, supported by the most athletic lock pairing to grace this WC. Back row just packs a punch. The mobility and awesome work rate of Lawes compliments the physical 'don't lie down' approach that the too hot to handle Curry brings. An electric 9, maestro 10 and a 12 & 13 combo that can dance or ram their way through a wall of defence whilst keeping the ball alive. It's hard to find a weakness. Should that not be enough we have out wide the 'speedsters', both willing and more than able to run sideways across the pitch to make those game changing 5 metres.
Too much talent? Perhaps. But at 15 we have safety with a capital 'S' and then, to wrap it up, a vocal clappy happy Chappy at 8 to frustrate the opposition and officials.
...... Yes, we can begin to dream.![]()
I’m watching the matches vs Chile & Samoa and the group were joking today that we might at least get to see one victory.
- Mr Mwenda
- Posts: 2461
- Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:42 am
Re: England vs Argentina
I assumed it was the gripe water.Oakboy wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 7:13 pmHave you been on the laughing gas?p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 6:44 pm Really pleased with the side. I believe SB has nailed this. After 4 games testing out options and different game plans he has settled on a starting XV that will bring together the pluses from the one win and 3 defeats.
Strong front row, supported by the most athletic lock pairing to grace this WC. Back row just packs a punch. The mobility and awesome work rate of Lawes compliments the physical 'don't lie down' approach that the too hot to handle Curry brings. An electric 9, maestro 10 and a 12 & 13 combo that can dance or ram their way through a wall of defence whilst keeping the ball alive. It's hard to find a weakness. Should that not be enough we have out wide the 'speedsters', both willing and more than able to run sideways across the pitch to make those game changing 5 metres.
Too much talent? Perhaps. But at 15 we have safety with a capital 'S' and then, to wrap it up, a vocal clappy happy Chappy at 8 to frustrate the opposition and officials.
...... Yes, we can begin to dream.![]()
-
- Posts: 3828
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
- Puja
- Posts: 17743
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Right on! Gotta keep the delusion faith. I still believe that it's all because Aled's been beasting them in fitness and we're going to peak right when we need to. It's all the long game.p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:26 pm The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
Puja
Backist Monk
- Mellsblue
- Posts: 14573
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am
Re: England vs Argentina
Who is this Aled chap?Puja wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:42 pmRight on! Gotta keep the delusion faith. I still believe that it's all because Aled's been beasting them in fitness and we're going to peak right when we need to. It's all the long game.p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:26 pm The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
Puja
- Puja
- Posts: 17743
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Oh, you haven't heard? Let me tell you the good news about former Springboks fitness coach Aled Walters...Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:47 pmWho is this Aled chap?Puja wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:42 pmRight on! Gotta keep the delusion faith. I still believe that it's all because Aled's been beasting them in fitness and we're going to peak right when we need to. It's all the long game.p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:26 pm The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
Puja
Puja
Backist Monk
-
- Posts: 2636
- Joined: Sun Feb 19, 2017 9:41 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
All you need is another shirt. Mine is blue with a little red cockerell on it because I am a filthy heathen.p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:26 pm The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
-
- Posts: 3008
- Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 9:14 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
I realise I have a habbit of coming on here to say this, but you lot need to be a bit more optimistic. Yeah, you have been rubbish and you have Dan Cole starting about 10 years past his sell by date but Argentina aren't great. They have the odd good performance but are inconsistent and are struggling to move from awkward opponents to being a really top team...
and even if you lose what I view as a 50/50 game, you will still probably get through.
and even if you lose what I view as a 50/50 game, you will still probably get through.
Last edited by Cameo on Fri Sep 08, 2023 2:44 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Puja
- Posts: 17743
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Oh gods. We're so terrible that we're getting pity from the Scots!Cameo wrote: ↑Fri Sep 08, 2023 1:07 am I realise I have a habbtbof coming on here to say this, but you lot need to be a bit more optimistic. Yeah, you have been rubbish and you have Dan Cole starting about 10 years past his sell by date but Argentina aren't great. They have the odd good performance but are inconsistent and are struggling to move from awkward opponents to being a really top team...
and even if you lose what I view as a 50/50 game, you will still probably get through.
Puja
Backist Monk
- Lizard
- Posts: 3810
- Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 11:41 pm
- Location: Dominating the SHMB
Re: England vs Argentina
Not to mention a paste and tape Manu Tuilagi coming on to play crash at the age of 32...Cameo wrote: ↑Fri Sep 08, 2023 1:07 am I realise I have a habbtbof coming on here to say this, but you lot need to be a bit more optimistic. Yeah, you have been rubbish and you have Dan Cole starting about 10 years past his sell by date but Argentina aren't great. They have the odd good performance but are inconsistent and are struggling to move from awkward opponents to being a really top team...
and even if you lose what I view as a 50/50 game, you will still probably get through.
______________________
Dominating the SHMB
======================
Dominating the SHMB
======================
- jngf
- Posts: 1574
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 5:57 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Jones?Mellsblue wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:47 pmWho is this Aled chap?Puja wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:42 pmRight on! Gotta keep the delusion faith. I still believe that it's all because Aled's been beasting them in fitness and we're going to peak right when we need to. It's all the long game.p/d wrote: ↑Thu Sep 07, 2023 9:26 pm The mocking is over, the time has come to spin it whichever way to fill me with hope and expectation
There will be power, cohesion and stunning tries…… but we will match them and take the spoils. Amongst friends I will cheer, curse and question much. But at the end I will believe and celebrate the view as we again look down, without fear,on those who stand in our way!
Puja
-
- Posts: 3828
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm
Re: England vs Argentina
Did he get his watch back?
-
- Posts: 1312
- Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:31 am