Vive la revolution!

Moderator: Puja

Epaminondas Pules
Posts: 3426
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:19 pm

Vive la revolution!

Post by Epaminondas Pules »

So, post the RWC; or Monday as it is otherwise known, what's the future?

There will inevitably be retirements from international rugby, maybe some pushed aside, and some new blood along the way.

Pretending Stunningly Boring bites the bullet and goes all shake n' vac, what's your squad look like?

Nobody over 30, 36 players + 3 apprentices. Who is in, who is out? And why have you picked Farrell as captain? Ah, the Ice Man has no age!

3 x LH
3 x Hooker
3 x TH
4 x Lock
6 x Backrow
3 x SH
3 x FH
4 x Centre
6 x Back three
+ 1 anywhere
3 x apprentice
Epaminondas Pules
Posts: 3426
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:19 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Epaminondas Pules »

LH:
Ellis Genge
Bevan Rodd
Fin Baxter

Hooker:
Sam Riley
Theo Dan
Jamie Blamire

TH:
Will Stuart
Joe Heyes
James Harper

Lock:
Maro Itoje - Captain
Ollie Chessum
George Martin
Hugh Tizzard

Backrow:
Tom Curry
Ben Curry
Jack Willis
Tom Willis
Ben Earl
Zac Mercer

SH:
Raffi Quirke
Alex Mitchell
JVP

FH:
Marcus Smith
Fin Smith
Orlando Bailey

Centre:
Joe Marchant
Ollie Lawrence
Seb Atkinson
Dan Kelly

Back Three:
Henry Arundell
Freddie Steward
Cadan Murley
OHC
Anthony Watson
Will Joseph (might not get away with that, but he has played wing..... ;) )

+1:
Alfie Barbeary

Apprentices:
Ben Redshaw
Archie MacParland
Henry Pollock

I've probably forgotten a fuck tonne of players.
p/d
Posts: 3828
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by p/d »

justice4freeman
Banquo
Posts: 19200
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Banquo »

Freeman has to be somewhere?
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17739
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Puja »

Okay, this is a fun game. I've probably missed about a dozen obvious names though.

Front row:
Genge and Stuart get in, but with an admonition to pull their socks up. Frankly, there's not that many options. Rodd appears to be our loosehead future and Heyes our tighthead future just on sheer inertia, although I really want the latter to seriously kick on this season before I get too excited. I'm hoping Haffar and Afolabi get gametime enough to be pushing for the third spot on each side, or at least to bring them in as apprentices.

On hooker, Dan, Blamire, Blake.

Lock's not going to be too much of a change: Itoje, Chessum, Martin all meeting criteria before we start. 4th spot open for the likes of Tizzard, Chessum the Taller, Munga, et al to compete for.

Back row is easier as well. TCurry, Pearson, Ludlam, Earl, TWillis and one of likely Mercer, BCurry, or the unlikely longshot of Barbeary remaining fit. I'd probably give the extra squad place to a back row, tbh.

Scrum-half - If we assume JVP is out, then Mitchell, Quirke, and AN Other. Depends who starts the season well really.

Fly-half: MSmith, FSmith... CAtkinson, maybe? Cupboard's a bit bare behind the current three and Fin.

Centre: No Marchant for the moment, so we'll give SAtkinson/Kelly a try at 12 and Lawrence/WJoseph the reins at 13.

Back Three: Arundell and Steward at 15 (in that order, if we're starting afresh), which leaves Watson, Murley, OHC, and Freeman on the wing. Wouldn't be suprised to see Malins in the squad - I think he's drastically underrated on here and will be having a lot of fun at Brizzle.

Apprentices: Afolabi probably more likely to fit in here, as is Chessum the Taller. Ollie Hartley would benefit from time in camp as well and is someone with a big future ahead of him.


Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Mellsblue
Posts: 14573
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2016 7:58 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Mellsblue »

Epaminondas Pules wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 1:35 pm So, post the RWC; or Monday as it is otherwise known, what's the future?

There will inevitably be retirements from international rugby, maybe some pushed aside, and some new blood along the way.

Pretending Stunningly Boring bites the bullet and goes all shake n' vac, what's your squad look like?

Nobody over 30, 36 players + 3 apprentices. Who is in, who is out? And why have you picked Farrell as captain? Ah, the Ice Man has no age!

3 x LH
3 x Hooker
3 x TH
4 x Lock
6 x Backrow
3 x SH
3 x FH
4 x Centre
6 x Back three
+ 1 anywhere
3 x apprentice
It finished for me 30mins into the Japan match…
p/d
Posts: 3828
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:45 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by p/d »

Hoping Langdon can join LCD and Dan for the 2 berth.
User avatar
jngf
Posts: 1574
Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 5:57 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by jngf »

If the RFU get off their high horse about picking overseas players, I would say there has to be a place for Sam Simmonds even if it’s at 12 or 13 ? Jack Willis and also Sam Underhill if fit - rather have all of them ahead of Pearson, B Curry or Mercer as things stand

Lawes ( with exception of replacing Itoje at lock for 6 Nations opener :) ), Farrell, Cole, Youngs, May, Billy all given their RFU gold plated retirement clocks … and add Sweeney to that list
Banquo
Posts: 19200
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Banquo »

jngf wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 2:35 pm If the RFU get off their high horse about picking overseas players, I would say there has to be a place for Sam Simmonds even if it’s at 12 or 13 ? Jack Willis and also Sam Underhill if fit - rather have all of them ahead of Pearson, B Curry or Mercer as things stand

Lawes ( with exception of replacing Itoje at lock for 6 Nations opener :) ), Farrell, Cole, Youngs, May, Billy all given their RFU gold plated retirement clocks … and add Sweeney to that list
bot
User avatar
Oakboy
Posts: 6396
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Oakboy »

I wonder if SB WILL go 'revolution' rather than 'evolution'. The question should be asked, "How valuable are OUR experienced players?"

My answer would be not very in most cases. In fact, some would be counter-productive.
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17739
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Puja »

Oakboy wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 3:32 pm I wonder if SB WILL go 'revolution' rather than 'evolution'. The question should be asked, "How valuable are OUR experienced players?"

My answer would be not very in most cases. In fact, some would be counter-productive.
There's a few that I'd keep. George has value around the squad, and Sinckler should get in on the principle of who the fuck else is there. It's not like the RWC squad is particularly old tbh or that we're talking about a mass exodus. Mostly the halfbacks.

Puja
Backist Monk
Epaminondas Pules
Posts: 3426
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:19 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Epaminondas Pules »

p/d wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 1:59 pmjustice4freeman
I fucking knew there was someone I missed!! Shit biscuits!
Beasties
Posts: 1312
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:31 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Beasties »

Tom West at LH, given VRR will be too old now.
Beasties
Posts: 1312
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 11:31 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Beasties »

Epaminondas Pules wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 5:04 pm
p/d wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 1:59 pmjustice4freeman
I fucking knew there was someone I missed!! Shit biscuits!
We missed a huge trick by not trying him at FB at all. Vying with Arundell for the FB slot will liberate our backline options after the WC’s over.
Banquo
Posts: 19200
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 7:52 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Banquo »

I don't think B Curry is a write off just yet. How bout Chandler Cunningham-South
User avatar
Stom
Posts: 5843
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 10:57 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Stom »

Banquo wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 5:13 pm I don't think B Curry is a write off just yet. How bout Chandler Cunningham-South
Will he get into the Quins backrow?

What about Kenningham? I wouldn't completely write off Dombrandt yet.
User avatar
Oakboy
Posts: 6396
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:42 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Oakboy »

Fisilau?
fivepointer
Posts: 5913
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 3:42 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by fivepointer »

Joe Carpenter is one to look at. Still think Fraser Dingwall has a lot to offer, Ted Hill and Alex Coles likewise. Will Porter will do well at Quins and should be on the radar.
Hooker is a real issue. I thought Blamire had something but SB seemingly doesnt. Sam Riley has promise but hasnt really got going.
Could do with a few young props making headway. Phil Brantingham at Newcastle maybe, or Fin Baxter or James Harper.
Epaminondas Pules
Posts: 3426
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 10:19 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Epaminondas Pules »

Baxter has come on leaps and bounds in the tight. Big season for him this. Brantingham starting to make some headway. Was very good in the PRC.
FKAS
Posts: 8468
Joined: Thu Jul 09, 2020 4:10 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by FKAS »

LH - Genge, Rodd, West - I mean that's looking pretty weak after Genge.
TH - Stuart, Heyes, Painter - again quite weak here, I suspect Sinckler will get some more caps yet.
Hooker - Blamire, Dan, Dolly - there's quite a few that could come in here but realistically George and LCD will win many more caps before these guys get a consistent look in.
Lock - Itoje, Martin, Chessum, JHill - again there's quite a few younger guys who could put their hands up and take Hill's spot we'll see where they are in terms of form.
Flanker - TCurry, Pearson, Earl, THill - need some bigger options and I think THill could do well in the Lawes role. Ludlam and maybe Lawes might pick a few more caps.
8 - Willis, Mercer
9 - Mitchell, (JVP), Warr, Quirke - with JVP injured and Mitchell's form erratic form we're somewhat crying out for a 9 to step up. Could well be one of the Sale lads.
10. Smith, Smith, Atkinson/Bailey/Haydon-Wood- after Smith and Smith there's a bit of a drop off to the next contenders. Sadly Farrell will want to carry on and Ford is only 30 so has year left as well.
Centre - Atkinson, Kelly, Lawrence, Joseph - not much in the way of choice here though Dingwall might get another look in as might Porter
Wing - Freeman, Murley, OHC, Watson - yes Anthony Watson is still only 29. Roebuck, Radwan, Thorley etc there's quite a few around and bar Watson none have a massive advantage on the rest.
Fullback - Steward, Arundell - obvious options though Carpenter is starting to look handy.
Tigersman
Posts: 1540
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 9:11 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Tigersman »

fivepointer wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 5:36 pm Joe Carpenter is one to look at. Still think Fraser Dingwall has a lot to offer, Ted Hill and Alex Coles likewise. Will Porter will do well at Quins and should be on the radar.
Hooker is a real issue. I thought Blamire had something but SB seemingly doesnt. Sam Riley has promise but hasnt really got going.
Could do with a few young props making headway. Phil Brantingham at Newcastle maybe, or Fin Baxter or James Harper.
Dan Frost for me will thrive at Exeter if he can remain fit. Capon will also think prove to be a very good hooker just feel he could do with moving.
Mikey Brown
Posts: 12176
Joined: Sat Feb 13, 2016 5:10 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Mikey Brown »

It’s funny how desperate we are to look at a fresh start even though we’re still in the World Cup. I think it says a lot.

Not many additions to anyone else’s picks, but it’ll be exciting to have a bit of a reset.

We’re in an interesting place judgement-wise with some of the fringe World Cup players. I don’t think anybody would say Arundell was a better fullback than Carpenter last season, for instance, but now is a time worth investing in the players with potential if not necessarily a body of work.

Joey Jo Jo Junior is going to be quality.

Absolutely can’t wait to see the back of Billy Bunipola.
Scrumhead
Posts: 5992
Joined: Sun Jul 03, 2016 10:33 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Scrumhead »

A few others to throw in the mix.

LH: Beno Obano (surprised no-one’s mentioned him?), Manny Iyogun
TH: Patrick Shickerling (I’m not a fan of residency poaches, but needs must and he’s eligible next month)

CE: Max Ojomoh
WG: Louis Lynagh

Lynagh is a bit of a leftfield shout, but he’s been out so long I think most people have forgotten all about him. If he can stay fit, I think he could put himself in the mix.
SixAndAHalf
Posts: 136
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 9:13 am

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by SixAndAHalf »

Another interesting question among this is who gets a central contract - sounds like there will be about 20 but it will be fixed for a world cup cycle. I have asterisked those I would have.

Here is my squad (ignoring the under 30 rule!) - I think it's will be evolution not revolution which I think is correct as I despise devaluing the six nations:

LH: Genge*, VRR, [Rodd or Marler]
Hooker: Cowan-Dickie*, George, Dan
TH: Sinckler*, Stuart, [Heyes]
Lock: Itoje*, Chessum*, Martin, [JHill]
Flanker: TCurry*, Earl*, Pearson, THill, Barbeary (JWillis not available)
Number 8: Mercer*, TWillis

Scrum Half: Quirke, Warr, Mitchell (assumes JvP* injured)
Fly Half: Ford*, [FSmith]
Centre: Lawrence*, Kelly, Atkinson, Slade (Marchant not available)
Wing: Arundell*, Watson*, Freeman*, Murley
Full back: MSmith*, Steward*, Carpenter

Square brackets for a few names I'm chucking in without much conviction.

Retired / moved on: Cole, Mako, Lawes, Billy, Ben&Danny, Farrell (unfortunately he will be captain and 10), Daly, May
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17739
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Vive la revolution!

Post by Puja »

Scrumhead wrote: Thu Oct 12, 2023 10:19 pm A few others to throw in the mix.

LH: Beno Obano (surprised no-one’s mentioned him?), Manny Iyogun
TH: Patrick Shickerling (I’m not a fan of residency poaches, but needs must and he’s eligible next month)

CE: Max Ojomoh
WG: Louis Lynagh

Lynagh is a bit of a leftfield shout, but he’s been out so long I think most people have forgotten all about him. If he can stay fit, I think he could put himself in the mix.
Those are good shouts all. I had thought to mention Schickerling when I started typing and then forgot about him. I'm not much for residency picks either, but at least with 5 years of history in the country, he's been living here for a fifth of his life - it's less tenuous than it used to be.

Surprised Obano's so young, tbh. Had thought he was 30+

Puja
Backist Monk
Post Reply