Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Moderator: morepork

User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17952
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Puja »

As Lizard said, the earliest possible date is Autumn 2017, although rumour has it that the tiff between RFU and NZRU over how much an AB test is worth may mean no game till 2018 AIs.

I'm not unhappy with that, tbh. At present, NZ are clearly better than us and I would prefer our young stars learn and develop in still-challenging, yet winnable games against Aus, SA, Arg, etc. Give people like Itoje, Watson, Ford, etc another year and we'll be in a much better position.

Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Eugene Wrayburn
Posts: 2315
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:32 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Eugene Wrayburn »

Puja wrote:As Lizard said, the earliest possible date is Autumn 2017, although rumour has it that the tiff between RFU and NZRU over how much an AB test is worth may mean no game till 2018 AIs.

I'm not unhappy with that, tbh. At present, NZ are clearly better than us and I would prefer our young stars learn and develop in still-challenging, yet winnable games against Aus, SA, Arg, etc. Give people like Itoje, Watson, Ford, etc another year and we'll be in a much better position.

Puja
And so will they. They'll be hardened by a test series against the Lions and numerous fights against quality opposition in the 4N. This is a better time to play the ABs than any time in about 7 years.
I refuse to have a battle of wits with an unarmed person.

NS. Gone but not forgotten.
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17952
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Puja »

Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Puja wrote:As Lizard said, the earliest possible date is Autumn 2017, although rumour has it that the tiff between RFU and NZRU over how much an AB test is worth may mean no game till 2018 AIs.

I'm not unhappy with that, tbh. At present, NZ are clearly better than us and I would prefer our young stars learn and develop in still-challenging, yet winnable games against Aus, SA, Arg, etc. Give people like Itoje, Watson, Ford, etc another year and we'll be in a much better position.

Puja
And so will they. They'll be hardened by a test series against the Lions and numerous fights against quality opposition in the 4N. This is a better time to play the ABs than any time in about 7 years.
I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Len
Posts: 608
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:04 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Len »

Puja wrote:
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Puja wrote:As Lizard said, the earliest possible date is Autumn 2017, although rumour has it that the tiff between RFU and NZRU over how much an AB test is worth may mean no game till 2018 AIs.

I'm not unhappy with that, tbh. At present, NZ are clearly better than us and I would prefer our young stars learn and develop in still-challenging, yet winnable games against Aus, SA, Arg, etc. Give people like Itoje, Watson, Ford, etc another year and we'll be in a much better position.

Puja
And so will they. They'll be hardened by a test series against the Lions and numerous fights against quality opposition in the 4N. This is a better time to play the ABs than any time in about 7 years.
I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
Or England could go the other way and regress when the new coach honeymoon period is over.
User avatar
Eugene Wrayburn
Posts: 2315
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:32 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Eugene Wrayburn »

Puja wrote:
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Puja wrote:As Lizard said, the earliest possible date is Autumn 2017, although rumour has it that the tiff between RFU and NZRU over how much an AB test is worth may mean no game till 2018 AIs.

I'm not unhappy with that, tbh. At present, NZ are clearly better than us and I would prefer our young stars learn and develop in still-challenging, yet winnable games against Aus, SA, Arg, etc. Give people like Itoje, Watson, Ford, etc another year and we'll be in a much better position.

Puja
And so will they. They'll be hardened by a test series against the Lions and numerous fights against quality opposition in the 4N. This is a better time to play the ABs than any time in about 7 years.
I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
I think they've got at least as much scope for improvement as you do. There are plenty of greenhorns around their squad. Take Ardie Savea for example. If he becomes the player I think he could be then we'll be seeing something utterly exceptional and relegate the very good Sam Cane to a bit part player. They've also got an entirely new midfield to bed in.
I refuse to have a battle of wits with an unarmed person.

NS. Gone but not forgotten.
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17952
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Puja »

Len wrote:
Puja wrote: I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
Or England could go the other way and regress when the new coach honeymoon period is over.
Or NZ could fall away after their invincibility aura is punctured by a couple of teams. Who knows?

I'm not sure how much of our upswing is due to Eddie - we have got a phenomenal group of young players and, absent the selection errors and abrupt swings of tactics that punctuated the last years of Lancaster, it's not that surprising that they've started to impress.

Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17952
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Puja »

Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Puja wrote:
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
And so will they. They'll be hardened by a test series against the Lions and numerous fights against quality opposition in the 4N. This is a better time to play the ABs than any time in about 7 years.
I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
I think they've got at least as much scope for improvement as you do. There are plenty of greenhorns around their squad. Take Ardie Savea for example. If he becomes the player I think he could be then we'll be seeing something utterly exceptional and relegate the very good Sam Cane to a bit part player. They've also got an entirely new midfield to bed in.
Yeah, but there's a lot more room to improve between average and very good, than there is between very good and slightly better. Plus the improvements are much easier to effect from a lower starting position.

Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Len
Posts: 608
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:04 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Len »

Puja wrote:
Len wrote:
Puja wrote: I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
Or England could go the other way and regress when the new coach honeymoon period is over.
Or NZ could fall away after their invincibility aura is punctured by a couple of teams. Who knows?

I'm not sure how much of our upswing is due to Eddie - we have got a phenomenal group of young players and, absent the selection errors and abrupt swings of tactics that punctuated the last years of Lancaster, it's not that surprising that they've started to impress.

Puja
NZ could lose the aura, but did we between 2011 and 2015? We'll just have to see. Englands 9/10 positions are weak and England are still selecting players like Nowell, who lets be honest isn't that great. And depth?
User avatar
Puja
Posts: 17952
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 9:16 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Puja »

Len wrote:
Puja wrote:
Len wrote:
Or England could go the other way and regress when the new coach honeymoon period is over.
Or NZ could fall away after their invincibility aura is punctured by a couple of teams. Who knows?

I'm not sure how much of our upswing is due to Eddie - we have got a phenomenal group of young players and, absent the selection errors and abrupt swings of tactics that punctuated the last years of Lancaster, it's not that surprising that they've started to impress.

Puja
NZ could lose the aura, but did we between 2011 and 2015? We'll just have to see. Englands 9/10 positions are weak and England are still selecting players like Nowell, who lets be honest isn't that great. And depth?
Well, you didn't really do much losing between 2011 and 2015!

And yes, we have still got (a lot of) weaknesses right now. That's pretty much exactly why I don't want to play your lot until we've fixed some of them.

Puja
Backist Monk
User avatar
Eugene Wrayburn
Posts: 2315
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:32 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Eugene Wrayburn »

Puja wrote:
Eugene Wrayburn wrote:
Puja wrote:
I'm still comfortable - we've got a much bigger scope for improvement than they do. In 2 years, there's a possibility we could be confronting them as near equals, which I'd prefer to being plucky and trying to catch them unawares.

Puja
I think they've got at least as much scope for improvement as you do. There are plenty of greenhorns around their squad. Take Ardie Savea for example. If he becomes the player I think he could be then we'll be seeing something utterly exceptional and relegate the very good Sam Cane to a bit part player. They've also got an entirely new midfield to bed in.
Yeah, but there's a lot more room to improve between average and very good, than there is between very good and slightly better. Plus the improvements are much easier to effect from a lower starting position.

Puja
I'm afraid from what I've seen in super rugby this year and looking at who's injured they've got plenty of scope to improve as a unit. As comforting as it may be to think "That exceptional team surely can't get much better" I just don't think it's true given that many of the players are at the same stage of development as your players.
I refuse to have a battle of wits with an unarmed person.

NS. Gone but not forgotten.
User avatar
Len
Posts: 608
Joined: Fri Feb 12, 2016 1:04 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Len »

Puja wrote:
Len wrote:
Puja wrote:
Or NZ could fall away after their invincibility aura is punctured by a couple of teams. Who knows?

I'm not sure how much of our upswing is due to Eddie - we have got a phenomenal group of young players and, absent the selection errors and abrupt swings of tactics that punctuated the last years of Lancaster, it's not that surprising that they've started to impress.

Puja
NZ could lose the aura, but did we between 2011 and 2015? We'll just have to see. Englands 9/10 positions are weak and England are still selecting players like Nowell, who lets be honest isn't that great. And depth?
Well, you didn't really do much losing between 2011 and 2015!

And yes, we have still got (a lot of) weaknesses right now. That's pretty much exactly why I don't want to play your lot until we've fixed some of them.

Puja
We're lucky something happens to your players after joining the premiership after the U20s.
User avatar
Lizard
Posts: 3851
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 11:41 pm
Location: Dominating the SHMB

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Lizard »

There is certainly scope for the All Blacks to improve. Of the 4 halves played against Aussie, only one was truly great.

The perfect game is yet to be played.
______________________
Dominating the SHMB
======================
zer0
Posts: 938
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 8:11 pm

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by zer0 »

The first half of Sydney wasn't even that great. It was just good defence and basic catch-and-pass again an Australian team that quickly capitulated. They'll need to be much better on the away legs, and I believe that they will be.
User avatar
Lizard
Posts: 3851
Joined: Tue Feb 09, 2016 11:41 pm
Location: Dominating the SHMB

Re: Bledisloe II: a pakeha, a Maori, a Fijian and two hookers walk into a bar...

Post by Lizard »

Yep. You should mention that to the English.

The Aus v SA legs of the RC will be interesting.
______________________
Dominating the SHMB
======================
Post Reply